Reviews
What User doesn't like about New York Bagel Pizza Co:
The order was completely wrong. I didn't ask for cheese, I got cheese on my bagel. I can't eat cheese. My other bagel, I asked for white bread, they gave us wheat. My father can't eat wheat, we both have Crohns. It's not like I could get it back there so they can get it back because they were from most things. Very regrettable. Why can't you just do things like a person ordered it? View all feedback. What User likes about New York Bagel Pizza Co:
I love this place! It changed hands back early summer 2022, but it still keeps the local feeling on it. The bagels are fresh and the beach n breakfast sandwich was cooked to order. You can do Mega-Kette Fast Food... but why would you if you had this big little jewel so close. #supportlocal View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Such a great find! I’m a New Yorker and it’s easy to find a real New York Bagel outside of New York. But this place gets their Bagels from the Bronx. I has the...
read moreI love this place! It changed hands back in the early summer 2022 but it still maintains that local feel to it. The bagels are fresh and the Beach n Breakfast s...
read moreStaff was very friendly and attentive which is always nice. Had planned to buy a half dozen bagels to take home from our vacation. Arrived around 7:30 a.m., and...
read moreSuch a variety that everyone in our family was happy. The staff was really nice about all our preferences and dietary restrictions, and everything tasted great.
Order was completely wrong. I asked for no cheese, was given cheese on my bagel. I can't eat cheese. My other bagel, I asked for white bread, they gave us wheat...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI love this place! It changed hands back early summer 2022, but it still keeps the local feeling on it. The bagels are fresh and the beach n breakfast sandwich...
read moreThe order was completely wrong. I didn't ask for cheese, I got cheese on my bagel. I can't eat cheese. My other bagel, I asked for white bread, they gave us whe...
read moreAfter a morning of fishing we packed some sandwiches to take and eat on the beach. Everyone in our group ordered something different and it was pretty good. It...
read moreWe starved on the way to the beach so we had a quick stop to get a bite and went to this sandwich shop. They ran out of a simple bagel, so I got the rainbow. It...
read moreI really wanted to like this place, but the owners are so mean. The husband is just miserable looking and miserable acting. Don?t expect a good honest reaction...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more