Firefly Bagels - Olean

#18 - Seafood - Olean, Bagels, Bakeries
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Firefly Bagels

Firefly Bagels
4.6 / 5 (10 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Firefly Bagels in Olean. At the moment, there are 16 menus and drinks on the menu.

Located within a quaint food market, Firefly Bagels has quickly become a beloved destination in Olean, NY. Renowned for its exceptional bagels that rival those found in New York City, the menu features an array of creative sandwiches, including a standout Chicken Salad BLT and the exclusive Manhattan sandwich on a pretzel bagel. While the quality of food is consistently praised, some diners noted a need for improved customer service. Despite minor hiccups, the friendly staff and the shop’s charm ensure a delightful experience that compels visitors to return. A must-visit for any food enthusiast!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: R

Images

Firefly Bagels Food Firefly Bagels Food Firefly Bagels Drink Firefly Bagels Outside Firefly Bagels Food

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 10 reviews

Was Tammy M at Firefly Bagels a mag?
What a fantastic hidden gem in Olean! The cute design is a delightful surprise when you walk through the food market and find Firefly tucked away in the back corner. There are so many creative sandwich options that it's hard to choose a favorite, but the Chicken Salad BLT and the Manhattan Classic with smoked salmon are definitely among the top contenders. The staff is very friendly, too. We visit every time we see o... View all feedback.

What Benjamin Urf dislikes about Firefly Bagels:
The bagels were very good but the customer service was not. We were standing there for at least five minutes before anyone walked up to us. There was an older lady who just kept looking at us and not walk up to us and ask us to take our order. Then we ordered a half a dozen bagels and I was told there was no everything bagels even though I could see inside the container that said everything that there was one. She th... View all feedback.

tammy-m-beach85
30.03.2024

What a fantastic hidden gem in Olean! The cute design is a delightful surprise when you walk through the food market and find Firefly tucked away in the back corner. There are so many creative sandwich options that it's hard to choose a favorite, but the Chicken Salad BLT and the Manhattan Classic with smoked salmon are definitely among the top contenders. The staff is very friendly, too. We visit every time we see our son at school, and we've never been disappointed! In fact, we just ordered 3 pounds of chicken salad to take home with us. The only downside is that they’re five hours away from where we live!

chauntell-nichols
30.03.2024

Firefly Bagels has become highly suggested for a great breakfast to have fresh and delicious. The lunch menu offers traditional and nontraditional options, I found great ?. Tuesdays dinner welcomes family's to take a break from cooking .I definitely had a great experience ,staff is friendly and helpful in suggestions and timely.

benjamin-urf
30.03.2024

The bagels were very good but the customer service was not. We were standing there for at least five minutes before anyone walked up to us. There was an older lady who just kept looking at us and not walk up to us and ask us to take our order. Then we ordered a half a dozen bagels and I was told there was no everything bagels even though I could see inside the container that said everything that there was one. She then said well too bad you came too late because it was around 1 o’clock. I heard her about 20 seconds before that take a phone order to use that last everything bagel. So if we were waited On when we should’ve been I would’ve got that everything bagel. Don’t get me wrong the bagels are very good but just need a little help on the Customer Service side.

r-b-restaurant069
30.03.2024

I am thrilled to have an amazing bagel shop in Olean, NY. Their bagels are truly some of the best I've ever had in my life, and I've been around for 53 years! My favorite is the Manhattan sandwich on a pretzel bagel—it's the only place in town and the surrounding area where you can find a sandwich with lox, capers, red onion, fresh dill, black garlic dill cream cheese, and tomato. The staff is also very friendly!

kaycee-gibbs-1
30.03.2024

Excellent food everything is quality quick fast service. As close as you can get to a NYC style bagel here in Olean! Soup, bagels, wraps, tuna/chicken salad, ids menu too way beyond just breakfast

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.