Anley's (formerly Pizza Plus)

Very nice people, Good prices, and Amazing pizza, if you like pizza come here. read more Very nice people, Good prices, and Amazing pizza, if you like pizza come here.

I have a strong feeling that they simply take a frozen pizza and put it in a pizza box. The quality of the pizza is really disappointing. The wings taste like t... read more I have a strong feeling that they simply take a frozen pizza and put it in a pizza box. The quality of the pizza is really disappointing. The wings taste like they’ve been refried from frozen as well. Not appetizing at all! I won’t be returning here. I knew I should have just gone to Teddy's; I just wanted to try something different.

We ordered a large pizza and a calzone for pick-up the other night. Anley's quickly called to inform us that they were out of ricotta for the calzone, and we as... read more We ordered a large pizza and a calzone for pick-up the other night. Anley's quickly called to inform us that they were out of ricotta for the calzone, and we assured them it was no problem and that we would try again another time. To our surprise and delight, when we went to pick up our pizza, they had prepared our calzone with ricotta included. We truly appreciated their exceptional customer service! The calzone was amazing and has now topped my list of all-time favorites. Bravo!

Had a wonderful meal with the family and got a great deal. We had ordered a large pie with wings and a 2 liter of soda, all for under $30! The owner, Caitlin, i... read more Had a wonderful meal with the family and got a great deal. We had ordered a large pie with wings and a 2 liter of soda, all for under $30! The owner, Caitlin, is very attentive and kept checking in on us throughout our meal and ensured we had everything we needed. The menu has lots of options, so there is something for everyone. Overall, the service and the food were great! Everything came out in a timely manner and was hot and fresh. Will definitely be back!

Great food and service. Small place but they go above and beyond to make sure everything’s great. Caitlin the owner is very professional and courteous! read more Great food and service. Small place but they go above and beyond to make sure everything’s great. Caitlin the owner is very professional and courteous!