Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.6 out of 5
Outstanding | 3565 reviews

What Erik Cohen likes about Bagel Boy:
Consistently fantastic year after year. By far the best bagels in the area, and I've tried them all. Expect a decent wait time during the busy morning and afternoon rush. Chocolate flavored coffee is incredible. View all feedback. What Richard doesn't like about Bagel Boy:
(6-8-23 10:32am) Purposely ignored at front counter by short woman with curly hair. She did it twice and actually skipped me. Big thanks to the nice Hispanic man who finally saw me standing there to hand me my bag. Really hate to complain, but it looked blatant. Bagels delicious as always!!(3-5-23) Just picked up a few bagels and it was probably the best bagel I ever had!! They need to have a line/sign for “pick up only”, but the quality will make you forgot that minor inconvenience fast.

Reviews from various websites

Restaurantji
3.8 ★ from 199 reviews
S
05.08.2023 - 15:35

Great food. Salads, fruit, bakery, bagels and a nice deli selection. Definitely why it has been in business a long time.

Ronald
05.08.2023 - 15:35

Ordered 2 poppy seed, bacon,egg, and cheese. Soft bacon and toasted roll. I have burnt bacon, a poppy seed bagel, and it's not toasted. I'm not sure why they di...

read more
Cathy
05.08.2023 - 15:35

Great food and bagels. BUT Idk if will oder anything again that go in containers that aren't #1 or 2 rated for recycling. Get with better recyclables PLEASE

Kristin
05.08.2023 - 15:35

Bagels and food are great, but I need to leave 4 stars because the ordering process is awful and has been for years. When you order, they don't take your name o...

read more
William
05.08.2023 - 15:35

Bagel Boy makes great Bagels. Today I had Bacon, Egg and Cheese on a plain bagel. It was delicious.

Sirved
4.2 ★ from 7 reviews
Kevin
19.11.2023 - 04:11

How this place doesnt have a 5.0 rating shocks me. Here every weekend. Place is always busy. Food is always phenomenal. One of my top 3 favorite spots in Old br...

read more
Antonio
19.11.2023 - 04:11

The worst set up I've ever seen. You cant pay for food unless your food is ready?? That causes utter confusion. People who walk in have no clue who's online and...

read more
Kevin
19.11.2023 - 04:11

I just tried this place, wanting to deviate from my regular place closer to home. I honestly haven?t had a bagel this good since I lived in North Jersey well ov...

read more
Kevin
19.11.2023 - 04:11

Very good breakfast sandwiches. Salads and Bagels. Staff are very helpful and friendly.

Laurianne
19.11.2023 - 04:11

BEST BAGELS BY FAR IN NEW JERSEY! The egg everything bagel with bacon scallion cream cheese is so delicious my favorite! They are always served warm fresh! I ab...

read more
Menu
4.8 ★ from 5 reviews
Gerald
26.04.2023 - 17:45

Good bagels. Long waiting time, but it's worth it. Wide selection of bagels and other breakfasts available. I ordered a garlic bagel with Jalapeno Omelette and...

read more
Kelli
26.04.2023 - 17:45

Best BAGELS NEW JERSEY! The egg all bagel with bacon scalion cream cheese is so delicious my favorite! They are always served fresh! I love this place!

Twila
26.04.2023 - 17:45

Very good breakfast sandwiches. Salads and bagels. The staff is very helpful and friendly.

Gerald
26.04.2023 - 17:45

I just tried to leave this place from my regular place closer to home. Honestly, I haven't had a bagel so good since I lived in North Jersey 10 years ago. As lo...

read more
Viola
26.04.2023 - 17:45

Best bagels ever. I used to go to the original Brooklyn location in Sheepshead Bay. But I moved to South Jersey in 2020, when I retired, to be near my kids and...

read more
Doordash
4.8 ★ from 2500 reviews
Edward
02.11.2023 - 07:48

Place is great and so are the people that work there. One of the best bagels in NJ.

Faith
02.11.2023 - 07:48

Basically ate a roll, they give you no egg on your egg cheese, the sliver that is on it they don't season with salt or pepper, the hashbrown wasn't cooked so it...

read more
Leah
02.11.2023 - 07:48

This place took an hour to deliver 1 item. do not order from here.

Eric
02.11.2023 - 07:48

$5.99 to add a few slices of potato inside breakfast sandwich? When I selected it I thought I would be getting a whole side of potatoes. Bagel Boy should be mor...

read more
Joe
02.11.2023 - 07:48

Overpriced small breakfast sandwiches. tastes good enough but almost no meat on the porkroll or bacon and egg sandwich

Int Restaurants
4.4 ★ from 866 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Old Bridge

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Old Bridge, 272 Texas Rd, 08857, Old Bridge, US, United States
"Delicious and friendly staff"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Old Bridge, 2590 County Rd 516, 08857, Old Bridge, US, United States
"This is by far the best Thai food we have ever had! The drunken noodles, chicken fried rice, and pad thai are all amazing! Five stars!"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Old Bridge, 2323 Highway 516, Old Bridge I-08857-1893, United States
"Not the same very disappointed"
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Edison (near Old Bridge), 1 Nj 27 #1, Frappe Joe Coffee Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews, United States Of America, Edison
"Good cuppa, nice bagels and friendly staff."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Middletown (near Old Bridge), 1090-1112 RT-35, Middletown, NJ, 07748, USA, Afghanistan
"Do they just want to make sure this sandwich is vegan? please let me know, thank you"
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: KEYPORT (near Old Bridge), 15 Main Street At West Front Street , Keyport, New Jersey, USA, 07735, KEYPORT, United States
"Great! Everything on their menu is the bomb-diggity"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Highland Park (near Old Bridge), 128 Raritan Ave, 08904, Highland Park, US, United States
"Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: East Brunswick (near Old Bridge), 723 New Jersey 18, East Brunswick, United States Of America
"Best sub shop in east Brunswick. Very good, fast on door"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Matawan (near Old Bridge), 759 Rt 34, Matawan, NJ, 07747, United States
"Delicious and fresh Service: Delivery Meal type: Dinner Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Edison (near Old Bridge), 217 Lafayette Ave Edison, NJ 08837, 08837-2407, United States
"The manager, Chris went above beyond to ensure our experience was"