Sugar Crazy - Old Bethpage

Store, Toy Store, Ice Cream
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Sugar Crazy

Sugar Crazy
3.5 / 5 (115 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Sugar Crazy from Old Bethpage comprises about 10 different courses and drinks. On average you pay about $7.5 for a dish / drink.

Nestled as a specialty store, this shop offers a unique selection of nostalgic candies, toys, and gift trays not commonly found elsewhere. While some praise its curated inventory and friendly staff, many customers express frustration with high prices and inconsistent product quality. Reports highlight issues like inattentive and sometimes rude employees, as well as poor management of line-cutting, which has led to negative customer interactions on social media. Ultimately, shoppers seeking rare treats may appreciate the offerings, but those expecting competitive pricing or smooth service might find the experience disappointing.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: unknown

Images

Sugar Crazy Food Sugar Crazy Food Sugar Crazy Inside

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 115 reviews

Was C Franqui at Sugar Crazy a mag?
Visited on 8/6/2022. Amazing selection of candy and cute toys. They also have pre-made chocolate/candy trays to give as gifts. Yes, they are higher priced BUT they are a SPECIALTY store. They have things that you can find elsewhere AND other items I haven't seen in years. Staff were great too. Added to my favorites list. View all feedback.

What Google user dislikes about Sugar Crazy:
As the girlfriend of a former employee, I sincerely hope that Jamie and Bryan are no longer managing the restaurant! The atmosphere was unpleasant, and they seemed to encourage inappropriate relationships between staff members, which is quite unprofessional. I used to frequent this place often, yet I was never a fan of the pricing, management, or staff. I always felt uncomfortable during my visits, and I often receiv... View all feedback.

edward-hartmann
30.09.2023

Just the thought of all the candy in this place makes my teeth ache! It's definitely worth a visit at least once if you find yourself in the area.

jack-1376
30.09.2023

There are plenty of options available, but the main drawback is that everything is quite pricey! It's a nice spot for a birthday gift.

google-69
30.09.2023

As the girlfriend of a former employee, I sincerely hope that Jamie and Bryan are no longer managing the restaurant! The atmosphere was unpleasant, and they seemed to encourage inappropriate relationships between staff members, which is quite unprofessional. I used to frequent this place often, yet I was never a fan of the pricing, management, or staff. I always felt uncomfortable during my visits, and I often received hostile looks from the young female staff simply because I was the girlfriend of an employee. I wouldn't recommend working or dining here at all—zero out of ten. Also, eliminating the ice cream was the worst decision they could have made! It doesn't matter how long it's been since my experience; I still feel the same way.

unknown-youthought
30.09.2023

As the girlfriend of an employee that used to work there, i sure hope Jamie and Bryan aren't still in charge! Very nasty and encouraged the employees to have relations with each other. Very unprofessional. I used to go to this place all the time and even then i hated the pricing, management, and staff. I felt uncomfortable the whole time i was in there. Got dirty looks from the little girl staff cause i was the girlfriend of an employee. 0/10 recommend working there or going in at all. And PS.getting rid of the ice cream was the worst thing they could do!!! i dont care how late my review is either.

ronny-rodriguez
30.09.2023

I've been here twice, there's always staff cursing and talking down on other people very loudly. I don't feel comfortable in this place at all for it being a children's store.

Menu

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR-Code zur Speisekarte von Sugar Crazy

Suggested nearby restaurants.