Federico's Pizza On Main Oceanport - Feedback
Reviews
Was David M Dwight at Federico's Pizza On Main OCEANPORT a mag?
After Kit's dental appointment, we headed to Oceanport to try out a new pizza restaurant in the old Enzo's location, called Federico's. This is the second location for Federico's, which already has a spot in Shrewsbury Plaza. Today, Kit sampled a plain slice along with one topped with sausage, peppers, and onions, while I chose a Sicilian slice and a sausage-peppers-onions slice. My third slice appeared to be a plain... View all feedback.
What Suzet Lewin dislikes about Federico's Pizza On Main Oceanport:
This was likely the worst pizza we've ever had. We ordered a Sicilian pizza, and as everyone knows, the sauce is key—but there was hardly any! It was mostly just cheese, and the cheese itself was awful, like chewing on rubber. We thought the plain pizza would be better—it’s hard to mess that up, right? Unfortunately, it was the same problem: almost no sauce, just dough, cheese, and an excessive amount of oil. We're s... View all feedback.
Outside Images
Reviews from various websites
Last update : 06.03.2025
**Dine-In Review** - **Meal Type:** Dinner - **Price Range:** $20–30 - **Food Rating:** 3/5 - **Service Rating:** 2/5 - **Atmosphere Rating:** 2/5 - **Recommended Dish:** Salads The overall dining experience was decent, with the food receiving a moderate score of 3. The salads stood out as the highlight of the menu. However, the service left much to be desired, rated at a 2, and the atmosphere was similarly unremarkable.
Good food! Great pizza! Amazing staff Service: Take out Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
I absolutely love a thin crust pizza; it’s a classic Jersey style and they deliver it perfectly! The ingredients are high quality and cooked to perfection. They don’t hold back on toppings either. It’s definitely worth the visit. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Had the Sicilian. Wasn't great, especially compared to the many other pizza options in the area. Service: Delivery Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20
Victor the rest of the crew are Family !!! Great fresh authentic food just like grandma made !!
Last update : 17.05.2025
Great staff, they make you feel like a regular. We had the Thai pizza with sesame crust. My whole family agrees, this was one of the best pizzas we've had in a long time. Wish it wasn't 3 hours from the house, I would come here all the time.
I read the counter back from you on the pizza from Monmouth Monmouth beach. I run a business as well and have been fortunate. If someone isn?t totally happy I?m not happy. I?m really sorry to have upset you but would you rather not know about the problem. We order from you continually and my guys go there for subs. I didn?t need the discourse about your family. We all have that. I?m sorry but that?s how I felt. We called to get another pie and willing to pay but you were already closed. Your husband is very nice and so are you. It?s only business and it?s hard to please everyone. I just thought my brother being unwell was justified in his concern. I?m not a hater and have lived here in town for many years and support all small local business. I?m sorry you took it to heart. Again it?s just business and in my humble opinion quality control is vital to good business. Take care
I read the counter back from you on the pizza from Monmouth Monmouth beach. I run a business as well and have been fortunate. If someone isn’t totally happy I’m not happy. I’m really sorry to have upset you but would you rather not know about theproblem. We order from you continually and my guys go there for subs. I didn’t need the discourse about your family. Weall have that. I’m sorry but that’s how I felt. We called to get another pie and willing to pay but you were alreadyclosed. Your husband is very nice and so are you. It’s only business and it’s hard to please everyone. I just thought mybrother being unwell was justified in his concern. I’m not a hater and have lived here in town for many years and support allsmall local business. I’m sorry you took it to heart. Again it’s just business and in my humble opinion quality control isvital to good business. Take care
1st time visit and won't be the last. This pizzeria fills a void in the once dynamite and historic age of tomatoe pie places in the Long Branch, and places like Frederico's in Oceanport. I got the Vinnie Rienzo pie. Highly recommend!!! All the othertomatoe pies I observed looked great and I will be looking forward to trying them.
If you find yourself in the area, you simply must visit Frederico's! Their pizza, especially the one with the semolina crust, is amazing, and you can't miss the Kouign-amann dessert (pronounced "queen aman"). I particularly love their breakfast pizza slices and the various chicken pizza options. I've also tasted their sandwiches, which are outstanding—large portions, a wonderful selection of toppings, and always very fresh. The owners and staff are incredibly friendly and seem to remember everyone's names, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. This kind of service is truly commendable!
Last update : 13.11.2023
I’ve had both the regular and Sicilian pizzas here, and I can confidently say that this restaurant is a must-visit in the area. The Sicilian pizza is outstanding and my favorite in the region. The regular slice is also ranked among the top three I've tried. Federico's is definitely a hidden gem!
This restaurant is incredible! Without a doubt, it's the best pizza around by far. Everything else on the menu is outstanding too!
Federico's is definitely the best pizza in town. The sauce is amazing! I really can't think of any negatives about this place. It's been my favorite spot for years!
Good Rated Restaurants near OCEANPORT
★ 4.2 / 5 (1837 reviews)#34 Pizza in OCEANPORT Italian SteakBlu Grotto
200 Port Au Peck Avenue Oceanport, NJ 07757, 07757-1426, OCEANPORT, United States
★ 4.0 / 5 (4367 reviews)#33 Pizza in OCEANPORT ItalianBlu Grotto
Port au Peck Avenue 200, 07757 OCEANPORT, US
★ 4.4 / 5 (581 reviews)#12 Pizza in OCEANPORT ItalianMia Modern Traditional Italian
249 E Main St, OCEANPORT, United States