Casey's - Oakley

#20 - Pizza - Oakley, Breakfast, Lunch

Casey's

Casey's
3.6 / 5 (173 reviews)

Description

Oakley’s Casey’s mixes hometown friendliness and clean, helpful service with frustrating inconsistencies. Cheerful staff and prompt assistance make it a convenient stop for families and travelers, but customers report lukewarm or stale pizza, declining food quality, limited customer parking, and occasional brusque interactions. The welcoming atmosphere keeps many returning, yet reliability concerns have driven some regulars elsewhere.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Stephanie

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 173 reviews
stephanie-mizell
22.06.2024

After using the bathroom, the redhead cashier decided it was a good idea to scold my daughter for standing in the middle of the snack aisle trying to make a decision. She wasn’t bothering anyone, especially since there was only one other customer in the store, who was near the beer. The cashier just seemed to be in a bad mood and picked on my child (0 stars). We’ll happily take our business to Mittens now, which is disappointing because we used to love this Casey's! Edit: There’s also no longer enough parking for customers. Employees used to park away from the front, but now they occupy all the customer spots.

aurora-huelsmann
22.06.2024

Oakley’s Casey’s assistant manager Todd and cashier Mel always greet people with a smile, courtesy and many times have customers laughing before they leave. Atmosphere is welcoming and friendly!!

art-gallington
22.06.2024

They have worker that is ever dose not care about customer her name is Mel Adams she she’s disrespectful to me and my girlfriend and I will not go back to Oakley’s Casey’s

terri-carman-1
22.06.2024

Some of your cashier people are very rude and don’t help their customers outside with gas pumps and don’t change trash out the store is very dirty

magen-friend
22.06.2024

Had our water plump go out as we pulled into town traveling from NM to ND. As soon as we pulled in an evening employee on break helped us figure out the issue and recommended a wonderful hotel. Store is clean, serve was above and beyond. Thank you for helping my family!

FAQ

You can also pay for your dishes with the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.