Sugar Tree Cafe - Nutley

Catering, Brunch, Cafe
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Sugar Tree Cafe

Sugar Tree Cafe
3.9 / 5 (176 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley. At the moment, there are 14 dishes and drinks on the menu.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Emily

Images

Sugar Tree Cafe Food Sugar Tree Cafe Food Sugar Tree Cafe Food Sugar Tree Cafe Food Sugar Tree Cafe Menu Sugar Tree Cafe Menu Sugar Tree Cafe Menu Sugar Tree Cafe Menu

Feedback

★ 3.9 / 5 from 176 reviews

Was Diego Rodríguez at Sugar Tree Cafe a mag?
The service is excellent, and the food is really good, especially the empanadas, OMG really good. The only thing i recommend is to improve the quality of the coffee you guys use. Other than that, everything is excellent. View all feedback.

What Stacy Tate dislikes about Sugar Tree Cafe:
I’m actually relieved it didn’t live up to the hype because my ex used to work here, and we went on a date at this location. It would have been tough to avoid my favorite spot because of that history. Thankfully, that wasn't the case, as my experience rated about a 2.5 out of 5. That said, I want to mention that they might have improved since my last visit over a year ago, but I won’t be going back to find out. View all feedback.

diego-rodriguez-elep-2
08.03.2024

The service is excellent, and the food is really good, especially the empanadas, OMG really good. The only thing i recommend is to improve the quality of the coffee you guys use. Other than that, everything is excellent.

takiyah
08.03.2024

Went with my sister for a little brunch hangout. The aesthetics get you but it kinda stops there. The coffee was good but the food was not which we weren't expecting. Got the sticky wings and it was cold when it got to the table (not a busy time there) and doused with way too much sauce (which I repeat was cold). Mac bites were good but not the sauce it was on. My sister got the matcha pancakes which she liked. The Lobster tostadas were bland.Recommend going to just catch up over a coffee or drinks but would skip the food

erin-mary-1
08.03.2024

The food was good, but I was surprised at the prices. I was here in the spring and it was about $105 for 3 adults and 2 kids. I came today alone with my 2 kids and was shocked when it came to $82 pre-tip. We just got 2 burgers that come with no sides nothing just the burger, a crepe and 3 shakes that were almost half filled with a thick cool whip that was undrinkable. There are certain places I know it’s going to be more pricey, but usually I get a lot of food for that price. I don’t expect to come to a local cafe for a quick lunch and after tip drop almost a $100 for me and my two kids. I like supporting local small business, but not at these prices and not for a small amount of food.

emily-velez-pilot90
08.03.2024

I do love coming here I like the boot in the atmosphere when it first opened I love coming a lot more because it wasn’t as busy but now it is extremely busy and the wait time has gotten to be a little bit too much and it’s hard to go and sit down and enjoy a nice cup of coffee with a friend because there’s no spots

janeida-fernandez-tr
08.03.2024

Food was delicious and service was awesome. Will definitely be here again. It’s such a great spot for a girls brunch. Didn’t expect the food to be that good, but it was great!

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.