Elisa's - North Bellmore

First time ordering here and I loved it! The gentleman who took my order was very patient with me (I’m new to Long Island and authentic Italian) and he was righ... read more First time ordering here and I loved it! The gentleman who took my order was very patient with me (I’m new to Long Island and authentic Italian) and he was right- the potato croquettes were DELICIOUS! I’ll definitely be back and will be recommending this in the future!! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

I went there with my wife and another couple on July 19 2025. The food was excellent for all 4 of us. For me the chicken rollatini was the best I have had in ye... read more I went there with my wife and another couple on July 19 2025. The food was excellent for all 4 of us. For me the chicken rollatini was the best I have had in years. The server was very prompt and attentive. The decor is very simple. Price per person: $50–100 Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 3

Group of 5 ate here on Tuesday last. Happy with food service. However when I went to pay my credit card was declined! On enquiry I realised they don’t operate a... read more Group of 5 ate here on Tuesday last. Happy with food service. However when I went to pay my credit card was declined! On enquiry I realised they don’t operate a chip and pin payment option. I was very surprised at this and rather embarrassed to have to gather $180 approx in cash from my guests!

Absolutely excellent atmosphere, food and service. read more Absolutely excellent atmosphere, food and service.

Updated! Take out is perfect. Can't wait to actually done here. Except they wouldn't let me do takeout on Valentine's Day!! The nerve. Update: 9 years later thi... read more Updated! Take out is perfect. Can't wait to actually done here. Except they wouldn't let me do takeout on Valentine's Day!! The nerve. Update: 9 years later this has become my family’s go to Italian restaurant. Thin crust pizza is amazing as is everything else. Try the diavolo pizza. My perfect pizza.