Cafora's Pizza - Newfane
Menu
A complete menu of Cafora's Pizza from Newfane featuring all 57 meals and drinks can be found here on the list.
Cafora's Pizza and Pastaria has been a staple in Newfane, New York since 1970, serving a wide variety of Italian favorites. From fresh salads to crispy chicken wings, there's a perfect starter for every customer. The menu also features submarine sandwiches, handcrafted pizzas, delicious sandwiches, and juicy burgers. One of the house specialties is the "ponzone," a large rolled flatbread stuffed with mouthwatering ingredients like meatball, Italian sausage, eggplant, chicken Florentine, steak, or Greek. And for those looking for a challenge, try the combination ponzone challenge, where you have to finish it in under 30 minutes. Visit Cafora's Pizza and Pastaria for a true taste of Italy in every bite!.
Images
Feedback
**Exploring Cafora's: A Culinary Gem with Room for Improvement** Cafora's is a lively dining spot celebrated for its generous portions and standout dishes, like clam chowder and pizza. While many patrons rave about the flavorful entrees, experiences with service vary significantly. Some diners report long waits and inattentive staff, impacting their enjoyment. Despite occasional lapses in service, frequent visitors cherish the consistently delicious meals and appreciate the friendly atmosphere. The restaurant's cozy interior may feel cramped, prompting suggestions for expansion. Overall, Cafora's remains a beloved choice for pizza and pasta, though diners might prefer take-out for a smoother experience.
We had the pizza, and it was fantastic. The service was quick, and the staff was incredibly friendly. We will definitely return. I noticed their homemade fresh bread at another table, and that's something I’ll make sure to try next time.
Dear Cafora's food, I can honestly say I've never had a bad meal there. It's a fantastic Italian restaurant!
Absolutely amazing! My friend, who is 100% Italian, has always disliked any Italian restaurant in Buffalo. He’s extremely particular about food, especially when it comes to anything other than his family's homemade Italian dishes. However, this place has quickly become our new favorite! The flavors are outstanding and truly authentic. The quality of the food is exceptional, even if it comes at a high price. I can't wait to return!
We took our grandchildren to this restaurant after visiting Olcott Carousel Park. It was a lovely place with a fantastic waitress who brought coloring books and recommended a small pizza for the kids. We really enjoyed the homemade French fries! It was the ideal way to cap off our day. Thank you!
Incredible value for your money! The food is delicious and very reasonably priced. As for kid-friendliness, they treated my grandkids to some fried dough, and they absolutely loved it!
Full Menu
House Specialties
The Assisi Italian Sausage Ponzone The Portafino The Portafino Spinach The Italian Tuna The Italian Buffalo
More information
QR-code link to the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 3.8 / 5 (2724 reviews)American North AmericanGordie Harper Bazaar
Lockport-Olcott Road 3333, 14108 Newfane, US
"The chicken and biscuits was so good."
★ 4.0 / 5 (1122 reviews)Breakfast Lunch CanadianTim Hortons
Main Street 2897, 14108 Newfane, US
"Fast and friendly,drive thru is fast"
★ 4.0 / 5 (1820 reviews)Diners Breakfast Lunch CoffeeBill's Diner
Main Street 2762, 14108 Newfane, US
"Our waitress was very friendly. The portions are very generous."