Brooklyn Pizza - Newburgh

I want to start by first saying this is a small locally owned business that just like everyone else during Covid I’m sure went through struggles that effected the business. I find some of the previous reviews to be completely unsympathetic to the littlest of complaints. Everyone runs to post an ugly review when “unhappy” to have a voice but I promise you for every one bad review Danny the owner has dozens of great reviews from customers and people who support his hard work and good food. I have zero complaints about the food from Brooklyn Pizza and certainly enjoy my favorite and exclusive “Buffalo Knots.” They are addicting! The Owner Danny comes from a Pizzeria bloodline and continues to work extremely hard at preserving the old school way and family sauce. He treats everyone like family and goes above and beyond for the community. He’s the guy who would give you the shirt off your back and for that he 100% has my business for not only that but great, honest, local delicious pizza! A must go, especially for those Buffalo knows, if you haven’t tried them you’re missing out I promise!!

Stopped in on a hunch. I was not disappointed! Ordered a couple plain slices and they were excellent! Thin, perfectly cooked, nice sauce and just the right amount of cheese. I will be back for sure

Me and my Wife are New Yorkers by birth but now reside in PA. We miss NY pizza! We were in town for my Daughters wedding and leaving to go back home when we thought...hey we haven't had our pizza. We found Brooklyn Pizza and tried it. Garlic knots...dam good, and we got a large pizza to eat in the way. Thank you guys for giving us our great memory of the pizza that we miss. Would go back!

My mother-in-law says this is the closest to the pizza she had in the city growing up. Also good dinners. Recommend the lasagna.