Teddy's Grill - Newark

Grill, American, Pizza
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Teddy's Grill

Teddy's Grill
3.9 / 5 (509 reviews)

Description

**Restaurant Review: A Mixed Bag Experience**

Nestled conveniently within a hotel near the airport, this restaurant offers a blend of comfort and convenience, though it's marred by inconsistent service. Patrons enjoy a lively bar atmosphere with plenty of TVs but report issues with the quality of cocktails and food pricing. While the staff's performance varies—some guests praising the waitstaff for their attentiveness while others encountered fluently rude service—the management seems to be responsive when problems arise. A particularly commendable vegetarian pizza shines among the menu offerings. However, its lack of individual portions can lead to waste for solo diners. Overall, the restaurant presents potential but struggles to elevate the dining experience.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Charlotte

Feedback

★ 3.9 / 5 from 509 reviews
charlotte-605
23.08.2023

Alex provided outstanding service. He was very attentive and pleasant, making our visit enjoyable.

david-2972
23.08.2023

You remember Bro! Tasty burgers!

ryan-2334
23.08.2023

100% best food around! best service! Chef takes pride in what he serves. Bartender and servers are top notch! you won’t be disappointed! I base my stays on restaurants close by. I’ll stay here my next visit and probably the one after….

carl-680
23.08.2023

Vivianna and big al are the best

christina-373
23.08.2023

I ordered from the happy hour menu, but was charged full price until I pointed it out to the manager, who then went to the back to rectify it. I also had to ask for the beer I ordered, which was handed to me at the door. I spoke to the manager and expressed that I felt uncomfortable in his establishment, especially since they weren’t even closed yet. As someone who has worked in a bar, I understand the desire to leave at a decent hour, but I’ve never seen a restaurant lock its doors before closing time. After my initial experience, I updated my review from 1 star to 4. The manager, Mike, explained that they had an unusually hectic night due to a canceled flight, which led to a sudden influx of customers with vouchers. He also offered me a complimentary dinner and drink for my next visit, and I appreciate how he took the time to listen to my concerns and make it right.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.