Reviews
What User likes about Petee's Pie Company:
The standout dishes at this restaurant are the black currant crumb (featuring an intriguing mix of sour and sweet flavors) and the classic NY cheesecake (creamy cheese filling with a perfect crust), both earning a 4.5-star rating. The other desserts, including the key lime ring, brown butter honey pepper, salty chocolate chess, and Hudson Valley apple crumb, are good but not outstanding. However, the prices are quite... View all feedback. What User doesn't like about Petee's Pie Company:
Made with roasted chestnuts and cherries macerated in rum, Nesselrode pie is a cozy, nostalgic holiday treat popular beginning around the 1940s at many New York City restaurants and diners, it all but disappeared in the 1960s. Nesselrode pie is a chilled, creamy pie traditionally made with roasted chestnuts, candied fruit, and rum or brandy. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Made with roasted chestnuts and cherries macerated in rum, Nesselrode pie is a cozy, nostalgic holiday treat popular beginning around the 1940s at many New York...
read moreAs Hugh lemon meringue pie lover, the pie did not disappoint. The staff was very kind. The price is good (and worth it). Highly recommend if you are in the area...
read moreI had slices of: cherry crumb, salty chocolate chess, and banana cream. All three blew me away! I couldn't pinpoint what about them I loved so much (crusts, fil...
read moreReal dealpis. davis is a profi and deserves several raises (and I don't know her so) is legit, ny madkirsche and pecan for the victorious make her please and en...
read moreAfter all the years I passed, I decided to try the cake. I miss all these years with absolutely delicious cake. they have such a sort of delicious cake. I tried...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI just had the pork pie. WOW Absolutely delicious. Ground pork, apples and cabbage. Sweet and not at all greasy. The crust was super flakey and buttery. Good th...
read moreHad the Vegan Gluten Free Blueberry Crumb pie for today at a Bar B Que . It was OUTSTANDING! I would give it 10 stars and I am not even vegan or gluten free!!!
Absolutely one of the best pies I've ever had! That cherry pie...oh my! Glad it isn't too close to where I live! I've had cherry, pecan, a coconut pie, empanada...
read moreMy BFF, son and I visited the Myrtle Ave. location yesterday and tried the Lemon Chess pie. OMG OMG, it was devine! The staff was very friendly and informative....
read moreAmazing pies! Amazing! This is a new shop with great reviews already. The owner is super friendly, great customer service. Did I mention how great the pies are?...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe strawberry rhubarb slice was delicious! I will definitely buy a whole pie next time. However, the rhubarb streusel was not as good. I enjoyed the tartness o...
read morePetee's is the go-to spot for delicious pies! I always go for the Key Lime Slice and it never disappoints. I appreciate that they offer both lemon and lime opti...
read moreThe portion of ice cream is very small. When compared to a regular pint, it is noticeably smaller. The pie portions are also small for the price. However, the W...
read moreThe Salty Chocolate Chess Slice was delicious but the Black Bottom Almond Chess Slice had a bit of a raw alcohol taste which I did not want (from the amaretto)....
read moreLOVE Peetee's Pies! Especially the cream pies and the crumb pies. Highly recommended!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more