Reviews
What Storm Chaser doesn't like about Old Homestead Steakhouse- New York City:
Attentive service in a cozy atmosphere. Food was good too. Issue for me was that a family (3 generations) was seated nearby and it was difficult for my companion and I to hear each other over the boisterous and nonstop conversation between the mom and the child. Was not expecting that. View all feedback. What RayW likes about Old Homestead Steakhouse- New York City:
This has been my go-to steakhouse since I moved to the city 20 years ago. Best value for the quality of the steak, best prime rib in the city, and, friendliest, classiest, and non-stuck-up staff in general. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Hostess seated us promptly. Breakfast choices are buffet or menu - we ordered off the menu. Healthy choices are noted on the menu and I had the avocado and po...
read moreThe food is great at Oscar's and we enjoy frequenting for Brunch, and recommend it to everyone! However, please note that as policy they do not accept reservat...
read moreStuck in Mickey-land for a convention, a group of us were looking for a Sunday brunch spot. Oscar's at the Waldorf sounded like what we wanted and off we went....
read moreBreakfast Buffet located in Waldorf AstoriaExcellent selectionExcellent food Very enjoyable experience
We had breakfast here this morning while staying at the Waldorf Astoria. The food was exceptional on the buffet with a wide variety of choices. Our waiter was...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreVisitors to this Manhattan steakhouse experienced a lackluster service and disappointment in the quality of the food, especially considering the high prices. The experience was described as poor, with slow service and rudeness from the staff. Some guests felt ignored and unappreciated, with long waits and missing orders. However, amidst these negative reviews, there was a positive note from someone who had been a loyal customer for two decades, praising the quality and value of the steaks and the friendliness of the staff. Another review highlighted a positive experience at a Sunday brunch buffet that offered a variety of high-quality food options and exceptional customer service. Overall, while some diners had disappointing experiences with the service at this restaurant, others enjoyed the ambiance and delicious food offerings, indicating a mixed reputation for this New York City eatery.
I hadn’t been there in a while and, frankly, was a little wary. I feared it might be resting on its laurels. An icon, not really a restaurant. Man, was I wrong....
read moreI read mixed reviews about the old Homestead steakhouse and was hesitant to go, but I am so glad I did. The food was fantastic! The service was wonderful, and t...
read moreI know what I am ordering and always get excellent and consistent quality and service. I can count on the place.
Very noisy and very expensive . The service was not at the top.
Great staff, amazing ribeye!!! Highly recommend it!!!!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more