Pizza Mia - New Windsor

Wow just wow. Let me start this off by saying. It's hard to find good food in Windsor/Newburgh. Without Pizza Mia this trip would of not been complete. Upon walking in On Labor Day! Mind you. Greeted immediately. Thank you guys for being open! I ordered ravioli with vodka sauce. Cheese pizza Chicken parm eggplant parm w/Penne pasta The ravioli was wow. I would without a doubt order this again. They really do care about their vodka sauce. Made with love and true passion. Chef being a chef from myself being another chef! Lol. The marina is well made. Tomato paste, water, garlic, basil, black pepper, salt and I can taste a tiny tiny bit of sugar and oregano. It's well made in house. Dough is made fresh each day from what I can tell. And what I can tell is always accurate. This is where I'd go for pizza in the area. No where else. Chicken par. Chicken was tenderized well. Juicy and not over cooked in anyway. Eggplant parm. Most places destroy eggplant when baking. This place? Well not the best to be honest. Needs more work and attention. But I feel that's ok. They'll learn soon. Especially with the other quality foods they make. Will I be back? Yes. Why the 4 stars? Interior needs cleaning. I don't care if you don't have the room to store sodas etc. don't leave them on the floor in crates for customers to see. You don't pay for a service to see that next to your table when waiting OR EATING. Is what it is, don't be upset. Get it right and get it going. No excuses. Business is business. Decor: ok no issues. Customer service: amazing no issues. Well done thank you. Food: pizza and pasta above average. Pasta made properly not under or over cooked. Bathrooms: N/A didn't use them.

Great quick spot for a meal. I had the buffalo, chicken, bacon, and ranch slice. Crispy and flavorful out of the oven. Paired it with some garlic knots and a classic pepperoni slice. Sauce that came with the knots was great. Will come again.

Definitely one of the best pizza places I've been to in the Hudson valley area. The new Windsor location is FILLED with tons of different types of slices. Literally any type of slice you can think of! I've tried both their vegan and non vegan food items and it was all equally delicious. They have three locations which is cool, but the highland location literally SUCKS. I walked in on a Sunday and was greeted by dry/sad looking slices. I walked out immediately. They shouldn't be part of the pizza Mia name if you ask me. If you're ever in the new Windsor location, get your food there! You'll leave with a full belly and a smile on your face! Check out their Instagram for daily pizza updates!!!

Great little pizza shop that was great at accommodating a big group!! The pizza was delicious and so were the garlic knots. The staff was very nice and attentive. The food came out quickly. The absolute BEST thing about this place was the kids corner! I love when a restaurant is kid friendly! There was an area with a little table and chairs as well as a fun kitchen.

Tasty food! And they have a VEGAN menu which is practically unheard of in this area. I mean beyond basic pasta and bread and salad. They know what seitan is. They have buffalo cauliflower. I am shocked! THANK YOU. I ate the gluten full and cheese topped pizza with eggplant rollatini and garlic knots crust. Yum. I also got the Buffalo Cauliflower which is delicious and happens to be gluten free and vegan. Yes. Yum.