Marcelino's Pizzeria - New Windsor

#11 - Pizza - New Windsor, Italian, Cheese
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Marcelino's Pizzeria

Marcelino's Pizzeria
4.5 / 5 (859 reviews)

Description

At this local pizzeria, diners can experience a mix of culinary delights and varied service. While standout dishes like the meatball sub and veal parmigiana earn high praise, the pizza receives mixed reviews. Service is spot-on from staff members like Richie, who enhances the dining experience with genuine care. However, inconsistency reigns, especially during peak times when loud regulars can disrupt the atmosphere. Although many appreciate the warm bread and flavorful pizzas, some patrons are deterred by uninviting service and cleanliness issues. Overall, it’s a restaurant with the potential for greatness, hampered by uneven execution in both food and atmosphere.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: James

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 859 reviews
james-cangemi
28.11.2023

This restaurant is one of the top pizza spots in the area. The staff is consistently friendly. I dined in for dinner and was pleased with the service. The food is rated 4 out of 5, while the service and atmosphere both received a 5. I highly recommend trying the pepperoni pizza slice.

albano-aguilar
28.11.2023

The staff at this restaurant is fantastic. My personal favorite is the grilled shrimp pizza. Every time we dine here, we feel like we are at home. I have to give a shoutout to Di Di and Rich. The delivery service is top-notch and the meal type is dinner. The price per person ranges from $30–50. The food, service, and atmosphere all receive a perfect rating of 5. I highly recommend trying the pepperoni pizza slice, margherita pizza, and meatballs.

jason-granata
28.11.2023

This wonderful local pizzeria is a must-try. The Romano pie is delicious and the owner is very classy. The service is great, perfect for take-out dinners. The prices are reasonable, around $10-20 per person. I rate the food, service, and atmosphere a 5 out of 5.

kimmy-c-1
28.11.2023

I do not live here but I wish I did after visiting here. The locals were at the bar having a great time and it was the best pizza I've ever had. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Bruschetta Pizza

russel-bellinger
28.11.2023

Great food, great service, great taste in music, what more could you ask for? From out of town and would definitely stop back in again, thank you! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

FAQ

You can watch major sports events on a screen / TV right in the restaurant.

The restaurant is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

You can also pay for your dishes with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.