Reviews
What Shauna Roberts likes about Brewster's Italian Café:
We stopped here on our way home from Northern Michigan on a busy Saturday night and had a short wait for a table. My husband ordered a spicy pizza while I opted for the shrimp Alfredo. We also shared the ricotta and honeycomb on crostini, as well as the brownie caramel tiramisu for dessert. Everything was delicious, and the dessert was large enough to serve three. Our waitress was friendly and attentive, and I must c... View all feedback.
What Ali L doesn't like about Brewster's Italian Café:
The ambiance and service deserve a solid 5 out of 5 stars! The exterior is charming, adorned with plants and heaters. I was part of a group of nine seated in the wine room, which was very... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
We stopped here on our way home from Northern Michigan on a busy Saturday night and had a short wait for a table. My husband ordered a spicy pizza while I opted...
read moreI've lived in New Buffalo for over 30 years, and anyone visiting should definitely try Brewster's.
This is a fantastic restaurant. The food is outstanding. Be sure to make a reservation, as it gets quite busy and is very popular.
Very Good **** Mary! I didn't like they put the salad on the plate with Pasta Roma! They do not mix well together and I don't like my food to touch! I always th...
read moreThey add a convenience fee for using cash vs. credit card... The food is ok but lunch was overpriced.
My family recently organized a Welcome Dinner for 20 people on a Friday night in the Wine Room. The space was ideal for our group, which was arriving from vario...
read moreIf you're visiting from an upscale city, this will definitely be your top choice. The wait staff is incredibly friendly and even playful at times...
The ambiance and service deserve a solid 5 out of 5 stars! The exterior is charming, adorned with plants and heaters. I was part of a group of nine seated in th...
read more