Brewsters Italian Cafe - New Buffalo

So much jum! to write literally as I still sit here – that's so good! this was my first stop on my solo trip bc of all amazing reviews and it is Italian as I! such a beautiful mood and delicious aromas during each meal. the ricotta and wane reminded me of home, while the lemon-borrower was an explosion of giminess. katie was a joy as a server and very knowledgeable about each plate. the personal is so friendly and welcoming. a must try!

The dinner for two is an excellent worth! a starter for everyone, common pizza and escape, then dessert and coffee. the beef bourguignon is one of our favorites to share.

Great, fast service! delicious pizzas and drinks. would highly recommend.

Eat and service is always very good! Soupen and salads and sandwiches are so delicious, as well as all their pasta dishes and pizza. Their royal biscuits should die!

We ate at Brewster's this evening for my wife's 51st birthday. We were visiting from out of town, our first visit here in New Buffalo. First my wife was referred to as a guy while she does have short hair, she is very feminine looking. Our server seemed distracted, possibly too many tables, we had good service but her attention seemed elsewhere the whole time. I ordered shrimp Alfredo, it was alright, but all the shrimp still had the tails on them. My wife is a chef and this is not a normal way to serve them in an Alfredo dish. We were a bit less impressed with your restaurant than others we visited during our stay.