Beer Church Brewing Co. - New Buffalo

I always make a point to stop here when I'm traveling to or from Chicago. The atmosphere is fantastic, and the service is excellent. Of course, the beer is top-notch too! I even brought home some of their homemade Limoncello to try!

The service was outstanding, and the beer was excellent. The atmosphere was enjoyable. The wood-fired pizzas were good, but the real highlights were the beer and the wings. I was pleasantly surprised by how Italian-focused their menu was.

The food was exceptional, and the drink selection was impressive, offering more than just pizzas. I highly recommend this place for both the food and drinks. However, the waitress was not particularly friendly.

I was seated promptly, and the atmosphere was pleasant. The prices seemed reasonable for what I expected to be an authentic, fresh pizza. The outer crust and cheese were fantastic, but the center of the pizza appeared to be undercooked, and the amount of pepperoni didn’t justify the $3 extra charge. The waitress was friendly, but she didn’t seem particularly eager to help. I’m not sure if this was just a one-time issue, but as a visitor from out of town, I had high hopes for this place.

We visited Beer Church Brewing Company for lunch one Sunday and thoroughly enjoyed our experience. We chose to sit outside, where the atmosphere was breezy and refreshing. They even had football playing on a TV outdoors, which was a nice touch. The pizza and communion bread we ordered were fantastic, and there was an impressive selection of drinks and beers to suit every taste. Our waitress was exceptional; even when it started to rain, her service remained top-notch. We were sheltered under an umbrella, which offered excellent coverage and kept us completely dry. Overall, it was a delightful dining experience.