Reviews - Panico's
Reviews summary
Overall, the restaurant received mixed reviews from diners. Some were disappointed with the dingy atmosphere and lackluster service, while others enjoyed the excellent food and reasonable prices. The inconsistency in service was a common theme among the negative reviews, with some patrons feeling let down by the transition from a premier dining establishment to more of a pizzeria. On the other hand, those who had a positive experience praised the upscale decor, flavorful dishes, and attentive service. In conclusion, while the restaurant may have had its ups and downs, it seems to offer a variety of dining experiences depending on the expectations of the customer.
Was JeffreyG at Panico's a mag?
Quick appetizers and Pizza before a show at the State Theatre in New Brunswick. Thought the apps were pretty good, we had two specials, Eggplant Rolllatini and calamari with shrimp, pineapple and red pepper. The Pizza was a disappointment. Not really a thin crust as promised, a little burnt on the top. The service was uneven but the overall experience was relaxed and enjoyable. View all feedback.
What Ellsworth McGlynn dislikes about Panico's:
The original restaurant was across the street from this current location ..they also had a pizza joint on the other side of the same street. For whatever reason they moved the original restaurant into this pizza parlor...not good. What was once a romantic setting is now a combo fast food grub hub. Looks like they do a lot of take out while trying to maintain an in-house dining experience ...just doesn’t work. Service... View all feedback.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 23.10.2024
Quick appetizers and Pizza before a show at the State Theatre in New Brunswick. Thought the apps were pretty good, we had two specials, Eggplant Rolllatini and calamari with shrimp, pineapple and red pepper. The Pizza was a disappointment. Not really a thin crust as promised, a little burnt on the top. The service was uneven but the overall experience was relaxed and enjoyable.
The restaurant needs an overhaul it looked dingy the windows were dirty. Waitress was not familiar with the menu or what the name of the house wine was or if they carried other wines (which they didn’t). Eggplant Parmesan was dry .
Servers were very attentive. Had live music in background for nice ambiance
Last update : 24.04.2023
Fast appetizers and pizzas in front of a show at the State Theatre in New Brunswick. Thought the apps were pretty good, we had two specials, Auberginen Rolllatini and Calamari with shrimps, pineapples and red pepper. The pizza was a disappointment. Not really a thin crust as promised, a little burned on the top. The service was uneven, but the overall experience was relaxed and pleasant.
The restaurant is in need of renovations, as it appeared that the windows were dirty. The waitress was not knowledgeable about the menu or the selection of wines available. Additionally, the Eggplant Parmesan was dry.
Food was good; but we were very disappointed that the elegant full-service restaurant has closed and Panico's Restaurant has been consolidated with Panico's cafe and pizzeria across the street. The menu is much simpler. This is a real loss to New Brunswick's fine dining scene.
The salmon is priced very affordably.
I thought the open table listing was not representative of this restaurant. It’s basically a standard pizza place with an Italian menu. Our seats had ripped vinyl. The table top was loose and jiggled around. Lights needed bulbs replaced. The waitress never refilled our water during the meal. My wife ordered a small chicken Marsala and I ordered a large chicken frances- but the portions were identical despite a $4 difference in cost. The food was ok but nothing special. There are many other options in New Brunswick to try.
