Reviews - Panichelli's Pizzeria

#27 - Pizza - New Bern, Pizza By The Slice, Italian

Reviews summary

Nestled in River Bend, NC, this quaint restaurant offers a blend of heartfelt service and delicious Italian cuisine. Diners rave about the authentic, homemade pizzas, especially the one featuring white sauce, bacon, and spinach, as well as the mouthwatering mozzarella sticks. Many visitors highlight the welcoming staff and inviting atmosphere, making it a favorite for locals and newcomers alike. With reasonable prices ranging from $10 to $20, patrons appreciate the value for an enjoyable meal. Whether craving pizza or classic Italian dishes, this hidden gem promises memorable experiences for all who venture here.

Overall Total Score
4.7 out of 5
Outstanding | 922 reviews

Reviews from various users

Sirved

Last update : 22.03.2025

4.8 ★ from 118 reviews
tammy-williams-churc-2
22.03.2025

There’s a hidden gem in River Bend, NC! This charming pizza place has a wonderful homey atmosphere. The food is authentic, homemade, and truly a delightful experience. You might only discover this spot if you live here or come to explore the area. The food is fantastic, and the staff is amazing. It's definitely worth a visit, and I promise you'll discover something memorable!

fred-hodgson-2
22.03.2025

The food is fantastic and the prices are quite reasonable! We frequently take advantage of their delivery service, which is always prompt and delivered with courtesy.

brittany-c-office68
22.03.2025

I was quite disappointed with this restaurant. After craving pizza while in the area, I checked Google Maps and was swayed by the positive reviews, which made me think it would be a good choice. Unfortunately, the pizza didn’t live up to my expectations. The toppings were bland and seemed like they came straight from a can. While the crust was decent, it didn't taste fresh. To add to our frustration, both pizzas were made incorrectly, but we were so hungry that we just decided to eat what we were given. Customer service was also lacking; I could hear the staff complaining and gossiping in the back the whole time we were there. Overall, I left feeling quite let down. I honestly think I would have been better off with Domino’s or Papa John’s.

sherry-jones-doctor4
22.03.2025

The food is amazing, affordably priced, and the staff are very friendly. You won't find better mozzarella sticks anywhere!

massholemama4life
22.03.2025

I would rate this restaurant a billion stars for their exceptional customer service and food quality! Since moving from Boston nearly a year ago, my family struggled to find a place worth returning to—until now. We visited tonight, and not only did a gentleman bring my food to the car, but the pizza was just as amazing as the ones I've had back home and in New York. Thank you, thank you, thank you—sincerely, a newcomer!

Google

Last update : 16.03.2025

4.8 ★ from 35 reviews
john
16.03.2025

The pizza crust has that classic NY style. I shared a large supreme with my family, and it was fantastic. The prices were more reasonable compared to other non-chain pizza restaurants I've visited in the area. It's situated in Riverbend, which is a bit further from the city center, but it's definitely worth the trip if you're nearby or seeking a nice place to dine with others.

tex-francis-1
16.03.2025

I had really great pizza here—definitely one of the best I've had since moving from Brooklyn to North Carolina. The staff is fantastic, and every time I place a takeout order while I'm in the area, the owner always comes to the door with my order and walks me out. No other restaurant has done that for me, and it’s those small touches that truly make a difference. Service: Takeaway Meal type: Lunch

michael-kelley-firef-1
16.03.2025

I got lunch from here today and had the Stromboli and a chicken Caesar sub. Both were fantastic! The sauce on the Stromboli was incredible! I ordered in person, and the staff was very friendly. My order was ready exactly when they said it would be. I couldn't be happier, and I'll definitely be returning. Service: Takeaway Meal type: Lunch

todd-gerard
16.03.2025

Excellent service and quick delivery. The pizza is fantastic! Make sure to try the cheese sticks too! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

michael-minier-3
16.03.2025

Wow is how I would describe it. I grew up in NY and I've been hunting for pizza, wings and cannolis just like this.....hands down the BEST I've had in the area. We're going to make this our primary pizza place! Service: Takeaway Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Heyrestaurants

Last update : 15.04.2024

5.0 ★ from 10 reviews
joanne-t-bird5
15.04.2024

The staff is incredibly friendly, and the food is excellent. The subs are delicious, and the bread is amazing. The pizza is exceptional. We're fortunate to have them in the Riverbend Community!

chelcie-l
15.04.2024

Panichelli's pizzeria is a awesome place for all your Italian cuisine, love the pizza and awesome subs... want a wonderful delight, Give them a try......

ray-c-farmer1
15.04.2024

It's official! Panichelli's has become my favorite pizza spot. The food is delicious, the location is perfect, and the customer service is top-notch! It's not every day that you...

joyce-w-library551
15.04.2024

I was so pleased with the pizza, and thank you for the ice. My guests enjoyed it too.

dominick-g-store39
15.04.2024

The food here is absolutely fantastic—fresh and flavorful. The customer service is outstanding at this family-owned local restaurant. They even make homemade, hand-breaded mozzarella!

Menu

Last update : 12.04.2023

5.0 ★ from 17 reviews
wolff-eliseo
12.04.2023

I had an outstanding meal and overall wonderful experience at this restaurant. The mozzarella sticks were some of the best I've ever had, and the chicken parmesan was incredibly tender - it practically melted with a fork. The customer service was also excellent, making it a perfect first visit. I highly recommend this place to anyone who enjoys delicious Italian cuisine.

huels-dorris
12.04.2023

Panichelli's Pizzeria offers delicious food at a reasonable price, served by friendly staff. Their menu is impressive, and you won’t find better mozzarella sticks anywhere else!

sporer-jaylin
12.04.2023

I would rate this restaurant a billion stars for its outstanding customer service and top-notch food. After a disappointing experience in Boston, I almost didn't give it a try, but I'm so glad I did. Tonight, not only did I impress my companion, but the pizza was just as delicious as what I typically find back home in New York. Thank you for warmly welcoming this newcomer with such incredible cuisine!

isabell-smith
12.04.2023

You have to try this place! I thought it was excellent. I’m definitely returning to try the pizza. I enjoyed the mozzarella sticks and baked ziti. The owner, Josh, was very kind and down-to-earth.

npadberg-restaurant0
12.04.2023

Panichelli’s Pizzeria is a hidden gem in River Bend, NC! This charming spot offers delicious, authentic, homemade pizzas with a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. You might not discover it unless you live nearby or take the time to explore the area. The food is fantastic, and the staff is friendly and attentive. Definitely give it a try—you’re sure to find something memorable!

Tripadvisor
5.0 ★ from 26 reviews
Restaurantguru
4.7 ★ from 560 reviews
Restaurantji
4.6 ★ from 154 reviews

FAQ

The average evaluation of this establishment is 4.7, which means that the Panichelli's Pizzeria is extremely well seen by its customers.

The community at Menu has offered these Pictures of Panichelli's Pizzeria from New Bern. They depict the meal space at Panichelli's Pizzeria, including the interior, location and of course, striking Clicks of fine dishes from Panichelli's Pizzeria.

Good Rated Restaurants near New Bern