Nappanee Bakery

#31 - Fast Food - Nappanee, #36 - Pizza - Nappanee, American

Nappanee Bakery

Nappanee Bakery
4.7 / 5 (906 reviews)

Description

In a restored indoor mall in Coppes Commons, a charming bakery anchors a collection of antiques and specialty shops. The bakery is celebrated for dense, hearty loaves, rich yeast rolls, pies, cookies, soups and sandwiches made with Amish-quality ingredients, and staff who assist with event orders. A spacious, piano-accented seating area invites shoppers to linger; nearby ice cream and a wide assortment of artisan goods make it a popular stop for weekend visitors and locals — note limited hours (closed Sundays and Mondays).

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Mary

Feedback

★ 4.7 / 5 from 906 reviews
mary-311
24.07.2023

I was coordinating food for a funeral dinner and Marilyn and the rest of the staff at Nappanee Bakery were extremely helpful and kind, making the process very easy. Not to mention that the food was delicious!

zozo-3
24.07.2023

If you ever have the opportunity, be sure to try their mocha cream cookies—they are absolutely delicious!

jacobscout
24.07.2023

Tasty food. Delicious broccoli slaw. Operates kind of like a “food court”, because stores and an antique shop are in the vicinity within the Coppes Commons building. Shoppers can walk freely through the seating area. Enjoyed our casual lunch before exploring the other shops and historical aspects of the building. Had ice cream at adjacent Rocket Science Ice Cream.

barb-111
24.07.2023

I go there to purchase the wonderful custard pie they make! I don’t even have to ask for it , they just ask me how many? Everyone is wonderful there

ukiahjohn
24.07.2023

I came to Nappanee with my friend Jenn, and she used to work for the owner Marilyn in another place before a fire years ago. Jenn brought me here a couple of weeks ago, and we loaded up on tasty provisions. The quality of the food the best Pecan Pie I’ve ever tasted brought me back to stock up with treats for a road trip and to grab a sandwich for me now. Things I have purchased here and love include chicken and beef base, garlic parsley homemade noodles, real pecan spun honey, chocolate chip and chocolate crinkle cookies, peach gummies, honey Chex mix, peppermint bark squares, a loaf of wheat bread, TWO pecan pies, soups and sandwiches. Everything is just delicious here, made with Amish (Mennonite? attention to detail, quality ingredients, and love.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.