Proprietors - NANTUCKET

Bars, American, Bar-lounge
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Proprietors

Proprietors
4.5 / 5 (1360 reviews)

Description

Nestled in the heart of Nantucket, this restaurant offers an unforgettable farm-to-table dining experience characterized by inventive flavors and a vibrant atmosphere. With a menu that changes seasonally, guests are treated to a varied selection of shareable small plates and unique culinary combinations that entice the palate. Highlights include exquisite scallops, fried broccoli, and creative cocktails, all served by an attentive and knowledgeable staff. While some dishes may be considered pricey, the commitment to quality and flavor makes each visit truly special. This gem is a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable dining adventure on the island.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Michael

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 1360 reviews
stelios-nika
03.02.2024

The food was absolutely fantastic, and the menu was the most exciting I’ve encountered in years. However, some dishes, while delicious, are quite overpriced even for the island. For instance, the heirloom tomato salad had only about four slices of tomato, and the roasted carrot appetizer seemed to consist of just one whole carrot, both of which cost nearly $30. Despite that, I still give it 5 stars.

your-other-woman-und
03.02.2024

We enjoyed delicious and inventive dishes at this restaurant! Our server was fantastic, and the atmosphere was incredibly charming. We were thrilled with our meal and specialty cocktails—my favorite was the scallion pancakes. The ingredient combinations were truly unique, showcasing a farm-to-table approach with a stylish vintage feel. We ordered several small plates to share, featuring fresh vegetables and herbs, as well as delightful combinations of textures and flavors with amazing sauces. Overall, it was a wonderful experience with impeccable food and service. We will definitely be back!

anastasie
24.04.2020

I've dined here several times, and while the food is outstanding, the service is just mediocre.

michael
03.02.2024

This has been a standout experience during our visits to Nantucket for the past two summers. The food is creative and expertly prepared, featuring layers of flavor. The staff is fantastic and very accommodating when it comes to dietary restrictions (gluten-free in our case). The ambiance, both indoors and outdoors, is delightful. The wine and cocktail selections are intriguing and thoughtfully curated. The menu mainly consists of shareable small plates, although there are also some larger entrée-style options available. Highly recommended!

stacey-mckenzie-4
03.02.2024

I had a unique dining experience at this restaurant, where the gourmet flavors truly stood out. It's definitely not your traditional dining spot. If you're willing to venture into new tastes and explore different flavors, this is the place for you. The menu changes with each season, and I found the drinks to be quite enjoyable. The staff is always friendly and accommodating. This season's menu focuses primarily on vegetable-based dishes, and as a meat lover, I was excited to try out the various veggie options. Keep an open mind! I believe the menu is even better than last summer's offerings. While the prices are on the higher side, I suppose that's typical for a restaurant in downtown Nantucket.

Menu

  • Mike's Market

    House Sourdough Loaf
    House Sourdough Loaf
    $11.1
    House Focaccia Square
    House Focaccia Square
    $11.1
  • Props' Pantry

    Jose Gourmet Trout Fillets
    Jose Gourmet Trout Fillets
    $13.8
    Jose Gourmet Spiced Octopus
    Jose Gourmet Spiced Octopus
    $17.9
    Jose Gourmet Tuna Fillets
    Jose Gourmet Tuna Fillets
    $11.6
    Jose Gourmet Ventresca
    Jose Gourmet Ventresca
    $19.9

FAQ

The eatery is a non-smoking restaurant.

The place also offers gluten-free meals.

The rooms on site are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physiological disabilities.

The restaurant also accepts credit cards from the common providers for payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.