Reviews
What User likes about Treasure Island Supper Club:
After waiting 20 minutes for a table at a packed restaurant, it became clear why it was so popular. The food and service were outstanding! I enjoyed the Ruben sandwich with onion rings, while my wife had the stuffed flounder, both of which were excellent. The staff provided great service as well. Don't miss out on this restaurant when you're in Dayton. View all feedback. What User doesn't like about Treasure Island Supper Club:
My experience at this restaurant was mixed. The 1 lb ribeye steak I ordered was 1 to 1.5 inches thick and cost $40 with sides. I have had better steaks elsewhere. The loaded potatoes were okay, but a bit dry. The mushrooms and sides were the highlight, but the portion size was small. I would have preferred them caramelized. The complimentary bread was from a typical food business brand. The coleslaw tasted like it ha... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Scallops were not good, they’re breaded when I thought they wouldn’t be. I guess I should have read the menu more closely. They were out of the rib-eye which wa...
read moreHard now days to find quality sit down restaurants, but glad I finally did. My t-bone steak was cooked to perfection! It was so tender and juicy and melted in y...
read moreService was fast and friendly and the food was really good! I ordered the ribeye steak, a side salad with the house dressing, and the potato boat side. I also t...
read moreThis visit was not a great one. Our normal server was off and we had Ca*ol. I only found her name out when I spoke to another employee about how disappointed we...
read moreA great pace with great food. The kitschy ambience makes it retro fun. plus they make wonderful martinis.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreSuch A terrible meal. It cost me 158.00 plus 25.00 tip. The waitress with long gray hair. Seem to know longer be interested in us once 4 of 7 people older peopl...
read moreA pretty popular place for locals in the area. We sat at the bar since the dining area was packed. It seemed like everyone at the bar knew each other as they we...
read moreMy wife and I have been following the events of this restaurant for a while now. I was really excited to try this place after all the hype about this place is b...
read moreWell, 3 strikes and you're out ! Revisited again. Different day, same result. Chicken spends too much time in the warming oven. 3rd time it looked good but was...
read moreTreasure Island is OPEN AGAIN and doing better than ever. When I went in there the other day they were packed. The food was great and the service was fantastic....
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe food at this restaurant is consistently top-notch. It's a hidden gem! The service is great for take out, and it's perfect for a lunch meal. The price per pe...
read moreThis restaurant quickly became my new favorite, thanks to its magical atmosphere, exceptional service, and delicious food. I highly recommend trying the Grilled...
read moreThe restaurant used to be voted the Best of Dayton, but it's not the same since the new owners took over. The original establishment was much better. I wish the...
read moreThe service was good The atmosphere was old style and warm The prices were very high The food was not top quality I was expecting a super club with music and a...
read moreStopped in because I hadn’t been in some time. Wow has this place changed. Poor service, bad food, and terrible attitudes. Not sure what’s happening here but it...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more