Reviews
What Ben E doesn't like about Cars: Sandwiches Shakes:
I tried a burger from this place and it was awful. I ordered inside and was told it would be ready in 10-15 minutes, so I waited outside. However, it took longer than expected, but that's not a big deal. The burger arrived cold, with a soggy bun and cold meat. It was a terrible experience. I do not recommend this place. View all feedback. What Joe J likes about Cars: Sandwiches Shakes:
We read about Cars today and couldn't believe we never went here before. Been living in Montclair for 10 years. So many fat sandwiches we could have consumed in that time! They were fantastic! The milkshakes were really good too which was a surprise. I rarely find a place that can make a good milkshake that isn't an ice cream parlor. I don't know what rock I have been living under but I never knew what a fat sandwich... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The employees showed zero concern for the customers. I waited for 25 minutes while my food sat on the counter for over 10 minutes. None of the employees bothere...
read moreI tried a burger from this place and it was awful. I ordered inside and was told it would be ready in 10-15 minutes, so I waited outside. However, it took longe...
read moreI used to really enjoy this restaurant, but my last visit has left me feeling disappointed. The fries I ordered were unseasoned and soggy, and the buffalo wings...
read moreEverything was very underwhelming, i asked for my wings crispy and received the complete opposite, i feel shorted on the fries, in the photo that’s all i receiv...
read moreWe read about Cars today and couldn't believe we never went here before. Been living in Montclair for 10 years. So many fat sandwiches we could have consumed in...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreCARS presents a tantalizing but inconsistent dining experience. Offering indulgent items like fat sandwiches stuffed with unexpected ingredients, many patrons are enamored by the creativity of the menu. However, recent reviews reveal declining food quality and service issues, including forgotten orders and long wait times. While shakes and sides like mac and cheese bites still receive praise, some customers report stale ingredients and lackluster flavors. Despite its potential, CARS struggles with operational efficiency and customer service, making it a gamble for those seeking a reliable meal. A visit may delight or disappoint—approach with caution.
I'm sure it would be nice if it were open in time. Local high school lunch begins at 10:46 and ends at 11:46. Place is 11 open. So basically there is a line of...
read moreFat Sandwiches? Yes, please! I made a party from here, and it didn't disappoint. The order was punctual and beautiful and warm. Every sandwich was packed proper...
read moreThe first time at CARS Sandwiched Shakes. It was true because the pizza place was closed. I am not much of a bread or sandwich eater so my options were limited...
read moreSandwich is not what they represent they are, as you can see, not buying meat on this sandwich and the 3 other sandwiches? Will never go there again and not rec...
read moreI was in the area and Cars was on my to-try list since I no longer have fat sandwiches nearby. Went with the 8 Fat Tony as it's usually my grease trucks go-to....
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe whole place was amazing. Great food atmosphere and great staff. They were very friendly and helpful.
Staff and food were both great! Definitely would go back.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more