Bennett Shellfish - MONTAUK

Outstanding, delicious lobster rolls! The owners are very nice!! The husband catches all the fish. It's a take out place. read more Outstanding, delicious lobster rolls! The owners are very nice!! The husband catches all the fish. It's a take out place.

If you want the best shellfish on the South Fork this is the place to find it. Fish is always catch of the day fresh. read more If you want the best shellfish on the South Fork this is the place to find it. Fish is always catch of the day fresh.

Had a truly pleasant visit to Bennett's we got a dozen fresh oysters and two dozen clams to go. Everything was fresh and well packed, and Kim, the co owner her... read more Had a truly pleasant visit to Bennett's we got a dozen fresh oysters and two dozen clams to go. Everything was fresh and well packed, and Kim, the co owner her husband were very kind and welcoming. Kim even learned how much we love tuna sashimi and gave us a couple of sample slices to try on the spot with a touch of soy sauce. It was absolutely delicious. We look forward to going back. Make sure you bring cash as of right now that's their only form of payment.

The clam pie is sweet and flavor full. read more The clam pie is sweet and flavor full.

I’m not a fan of fresh seafood but my family said it’s the best place to get the freshest clams and oysters in Montauk. The lady that runs this shop is super fr... read more I’m not a fan of fresh seafood but my family said it’s the best place to get the freshest clams and oysters in Montauk. The lady that runs this shop is super friendly.