Reviews - Overtime

Steak, American, Bbq

Reviews summary

At this restaurant, diners experience a mixed bag of service and culinary offerings. While some report exceptional meals highlighted by dishes like Jack Daniel's beef tips and fabulous chicken wings, others have faced disappointments, particularly regarding service quality. Waitstaff experience varies from friendly and attentive to inattentive and rushed, impacting the overall dining experience. While the menu includes unique and tasty options such as Portobello mushroom fries and hearty breakfasts, consistency in food quality and service leaves room for improvement. Catering services have been praised, suggesting that the kitchen excels in larger settings. A visit might bring both highs and lows—proceed with tempered expectations.

Overall Total Score
4.5 out of 5
Outstanding | 596 reviews

Was Vernette Derdall at Overtime a mag?

My friends and I went to this restaurant last Saturday night and had an incredible meal. The guys enjoyed the Jack Daniel's beef tips and sweet potato fries, which were amazing. My girlfriend ordered the chicken wings and Portabello mushroom fries, and we all loved the mushroom fries. Lisa said the chicken wings were the best she had ever had. I had the New York Strip with Baked Potatoes, and it was also amazing. Our... View all feedback.

What Loren Streich dislikes about Overtime:

My husband and I ate there Saturday afternoon. We sat in the bar area, it took our waitress a good 5 minutes to take our drink order, she didn't smile or even ask how we were doing. I could understand if the bar was busy, but there were 3 other couples in there and 2 we're not even eating. Our waitress made us feel like we were wasting her time. She never refilled drinks, she did however ask if everything tasted ok.... View all feedback.

Reviews from various users

Menu

Last update : 05.02.2023

4.6 ★ from 19 reviews
maire-pavlov
05.02.2023

I have had 2 different meals here. I greatly enjoyed eating my lunches there. I can't wait to go back. I had the Philly Cheese Steak. I have had better Cheese Steaks when I was in Pennsylvania. But don't get me wrong the Philly Cheese Steaks are very good. The Caesar Chicken Wrap is also very good. And again I have had better Caesar Chicken Wraps but the Caesar Chicken Wrap here is still very good. The real part that I think needs improvement is the side salad. It's only shreaded lettuce. No croutons, cheese, shredded carrots, tomatoes, or cucumbers. I do recommend this place. I would like to try their steaks someday too.

connie72-1
05.02.2023

Andie is a very entertaining waitress! great service, good beer and really good food. compliments to the cook.

ycorwin-grass03
19.07.2022

Last Saturday night, our group of friends dined at this restaurant and had an incredible meal! The guys ordered the Jack Daniel's beef tips and sweet potato fries, which were amazing. My girlfriend had chicken wings and Portabela mushroom fries, and we all loved the mushroom fries. Lisa said the chicken wings were the best she ever had. I chose the New York Strip with Baked Potatoes, both of which were amazing. Our cook, Chris Woodruff, did a fantastic job. Our server, Amy Beckman, was also excellent, with a great attitude and spot-on service. We will definitely be returning!

jdare-squirrel79
05.02.2023

The food was good. great menu options. wonderful service.

greenfelder-annetta
19.07.2022

Great food, affordable prices, and welcoming service.

Facebookpag

Last update : 14.01.2024

5.0 ★ from 6 reviews
vernette-derdall-flo
14.01.2024

My friends and I went to this restaurant last Saturday night and had an incredible meal. The guys enjoyed the Jack Daniel's beef tips and sweet potato fries, which were amazing. My girlfriend ordered the chicken wings and Portabello mushroom fries, and we all loved the mushroom fries. Lisa said the chicken wings were the best she had ever had. I had the New York Strip with Baked Potatoes, and it was also amazing. Our chef, Chris Woodruff, did a fantastic job (thanks Chris!), and our server, Amy Beckman, was exceptional. She had a great attitude and took care of all our needs perfectly. We will definitely be returning to this restaurant.

austin-schmidt
14.01.2024

I admire Overtime for being a staunch supporter of the military in the United States.

kelsey-hanson-1
14.01.2024

I recently used this restaurant for catering at my workplace and they did an excellent job! Everyone loved the food and their customer service was fantastic. I would highly recommend them. Overall, a 10/10 experience!

darron-bear-semmler
14.01.2024

I love this bar it’s my kind of place just walking through the front door puts a big smile on my face it ain’t too far come as you are .....I love this bar.

kari-miller-kirchmey
14.01.2024

Thanks for the great wings takeout tonight! Great job, as always!!

Google

Last update : 14.01.2024

4.4 ★ from 228 reviews
michael-murad
14.01.2024

The food was excellent, prices were reasonable, and the service was friendly.

julie-johnson-school
14.01.2024

Sean went out of his way to help me make my Dad's 93rd birthday special. Thank you again, I can't express how grateful I am.

melissa-schwalm
14.01.2024

This restaurant is one of my go-to spots. The food and drinks are excellent and reasonably priced.

Facebook
4.8 ★ from 40 reviews
Tripadvisor
4.1 ★ from 32 reviews
Restaurantguru
4.3 ★ from 271 reviews

FAQ

The restaurant can be referred to as one of the top picks of its customers. This can be inferred from the average evaluation of 4.5.

Good Rated Restaurants near Mitchell