Marlin's - Mitchell

#17 - Pizza - Mitchell, American, Grill

Marlin's

Marlin's
3.6 / 5 (1902 reviews)

Description

**Restaurant Review: A Mixed Bag of Experiences**

Located in a vibrant area, this restaurant offers an enticing all-you-can-eat buffet and popular Friday fish fries. While some patrons rave about the quality and value of the food, others have raised concerns about service and cleanliness. A few have expressed dissatisfaction with meal accuracy and food freshness, citing greasy dishes and rushed service during busy hours. However, many diners appreciate the attentive staff and generous portion sizes. Despite the mixed reviews, the energetic atmosphere and great music create an inviting backdrop for a family-friendly meal. Nonetheless, potential visitors should approach with cautious optimism.

Last update: 04.04.2026 from: User

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 1902 reviews

I have never seen two servers work harder or hustle more in my life. What a great job they do taking care of a busy restaurant. Good food. Good portions. Good prices. And I'll repeat great service. I hope management is doing everything theycan to support their good workers. I would come back.

loren83
09.06.2025

I just came from there. I'm not a picky eater. This was absolutely terrible. Got eggs, sunny side up. They were good. After that, it all went south. My wife noticed the hair in my food. I joked and said, they don't charge extra. The bacon was ok. Theham tasted like pond water and the stuff they claimed to be hash browns? I'm absolutely convinced they were cooked using dishdetergent. No amount of salt and pepper could fix that. My wife got the same food quality. I tasted her sausage gravy andbiscuits; absolutely incredible. No flavor and the biscuits were from the past. How far in the past? I have no idea. Servicewas slow, but our server Shannon was kind. My wife is absolutely furious with me right now for actually paying the bill. I'mleaving, but I will assure you, I will not be darkening their door step anytime in the future. Leaving photo to prove I'm not acompetitor or leaving a false review. You've been warned. I spent a night in jail once when I was young. Even that was somewhatedible. This really wasn't.

reva-morissette
09.06.2025

With busy restaurants there are always minor hiccups. However this one served us well and took care of every issue the over night buffet was lacking in freshness however the food off the menu was on point. I will eat here again and that's sayingsomething.

enola-mueller-1
09.06.2025

Just ok. My hubby?s double burger was good. Again as at the Sioux Falls location, the fries are not ?seasoned?. My food was lukewarm at best. The thing is the price is very inexpensive compared with other places. Service was friendly.

fay-tate
09.06.2025

Its a pretty good place, when I was little I would eat here with my grandparents when it was called I90. Just got done eating here again. Great food! And our waitress, Brittany was nice and helpful too.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.