Reviews
What LastManStanding likes about S J Pizzeria:
This place is my favorite place for Sicilian Pizza, or Party trays! I usually order a large Sicilian with extra cheese, Mushrooms Onions with the occasional Sausage, Pineapples, peppers, and sometimes Anchovies. The Aroma in this establishment was the exact same as it was over 30 years ago, the Party trays here are fantastic! Another fine establishment in Millville! Don't hesitate, place your order, ASAP! View all feedback. What Joshua H doesn't like about S J Pizzeria:
Just ordered pizza and probably one of the worst pies Ive ate. Burnt, bottom, somehow managed to have uncooked cheese through out the entire top. Mozzarella sticks were still frozen in the middle, cheese fries were cold, and the 3.99 funnel cake fries for 3 fries. Spend your money else where. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Not my style of pizza but my daughter absolutely loves it. They meet or exceed expectations for timing. The wings are pretty darn good. This is our go to place...
read moreThe pizza was really good and cheesy. Should have stuck with the Sicilian, though. Wanted to try round. It's not the same. Next time,they never disappoint.
Been eating this food for a long time now always a good vibes
Rude staff and it’s crazy hot inside there shop and there sweat getting on pizza real disgusting
Wow! It used to be good...pizza tasted like a frozen pizza cooked and left on counter and we threw away the chicken cheesesteak...gross!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe Whole Tray Pizza is perfect when hungry and craving authentic, great tasting pizza. Ive been a satisfied customer since literally 1980. (wow) I consider mys...
read moreLoved it! Give us more food than we thought. Plus very cheap
The party pizza is THE BEST IN TOWN. Always a crispy and chewy crust.
Just ordered pizza and probably one of the worst pies Ive ate. Burnt, bottom, somehow managed to have uncooked cheese through out the entire top. Mozzarella sti...
read moreAll pizzas were delicious. While I would order the supreme again, just know you will lose your toppings so use a plate. Or wait until it is not hot and less wil...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more