Barbaro - Millbrook

Italian, Pizza, Cocktail

Barbaro

★ 4.0 / 5 (705 reviews)

Barbaro, a beloved Italian restaurant located in Millbrook, NY, offers a delightful dining experience with an impressive average rating of 4.2 stars. Open from 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM this week, Barbaro invites you to explore a menu that caters to all tastes, including a variety of vegetarian options. To check current wait times or reserve a table, don't hesitate to call (845) 677-4440. If you're eager to discover more local dining gems, consider trying Cafe Les Baux or Millbrook Deli. We value your feedback—if you've dined with us before, please leave a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Rana

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 705 reviews

This restaurant presents an intriguing mix of delicious food and frustrating service. While some patrons rave about the ambiance and attentive staff, others lament the long wait times and inconsistent dish sizes, particularly the small pizzas priced at a premium. The fresh ingredients shine in dishes such as the kale salad and wood-fired pizzas, while seasonal specials impress. However, a recurring theme of complacency under current management leaves guests feeling undervalued. Overall, it offers a positive dining atmosphere, but potential customers should be prepared for mixed experiences regarding service efficiency and portion size.

Antonietta

21.05.2022

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Poor customer service, charged $40 for 2 plates that looked like they could feed a 3 year old, Margherita pizza was basically a plain slice, waitresses look mad and don’t greet or even have a welcoming look on their faces.

Bayla

25.11.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The food was really well done. It is Italian. But has a Greek name. Hugh Food: 4 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 3

Margo

25.11.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

We absolutely adored this restaurant! Everything was wonderful...we sat at the bar and Olivia was an excellent bartender and host. The grilled octopus starter was amazing and the seafood pasta was perfectly spicy and delicious. The chocolate torte was perfection. The service was great. We dined for dinner and paid $50-$100 per person. The food, service, and atmosphere all deserve a 5-star rating. We highly recommend trying the Grilled Octopus.

Rana

23.03.2025

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Omg what an amazing night! The outdoor seating was perfect for a fall night, the service and staff were so friendly and amazing and I can't say enough about the food. Everything we ordered was exceptional (including the drinks! ! Chef Nick Brower -amazing!!! Here is the chef with our friends Chris (bday boy Ruthie!!! Please go visit if you're in Millbrook ????

Christopher

23.03.2025

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Had my surprise birthday dinner here last night and it was perfection. The staff, the environment and the food were sublime! Thank you Chef Nick Brower!

Reviews