Yiayia's Cafe - Middletown

Mediterranean, Cafe, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Yiayia's Cafe

Yiayia's Cafe
4.7 / 5 (726 reviews)

Description

YiaYia's Café has quickly become a beloved dining destination, celebrated for its authentic Greek cuisine and inviting atmosphere. Guests rave about dishes like the exceptional gyro and fresh clam chowder, with many highlighting the stellar homemade desserts. The restaurant is particularly praised for its warm, welcoming service, where staff treat patrons like family, creating a charming experience for diners of all ages. Comfortable seating options, including a lovely porch overlooking a pond, add to the appeal. Overall, YiaYia's offers a delightful culinary escape that combines great food, friendly service, and a sense of community.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Elizabeth

Feedback

★ 4.7 / 5 from 726 reviews
elizabeth-s-church75
25.11.2023

The breakfast at this restaurant is both delicious and fresh, with excellent service. Don't forget to try the Greek coffee!

tracy-c-grass6763
25.11.2023

If you're in the mood for a Greek breakfast, this is the spot to check out. The menu has a strong Greek influence and the setting is a charming little inn. Parking is limited and there are only a few tables inside, but the service is excellent and the food is delicious. The baklava was fantastic, although a bit more honey would have been perfect. The watermelon feta basil plate was also great, I just wish there was more basil. The balance of cheese and fruit was spot on. We also tried a dessert with creamy filling that was outstanding. In summary, a lovely little restaurant overall.

tiffany-b-firefighte-3
25.11.2023

This restaurant is a hidden treasure! The food, especially the olive oil, is absolutely delicious! The owner clearly takes great pride in every aspect of the property, from the food to the cleanliness.

pooja-sharma-restaur
25.11.2023

I had a great experience at this restaurant. As a vegetarian from India on vacation here, I was grateful for the delicious food served by the YiaYia team. The service, food, and atmosphere all received a perfect score of 5.

daisey-l
25.11.2023

Literally your Yaiyai is cooking in the kitchen. The food is prepared with 100% love. I have never had a better tasting pita- freshly made. The food is so delicious and flavorful, you would think they just pulled it from the garden... oh wait! They did. You feel like you are sitting in a cafe in the Mykonos.

FAQ

You can use the WiFi of the place at no extra cost.

You can watch major sports events on a screen / TV right in the restaurant.

The rooms on site are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physical limitations.

You can also pay for your menus with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.