Papa John's In Middletown

I was pleasantly surprised by this restaurant! We chose it as a last-minute option since many places were closed on Easter, but they were open. The pizza was excellent and at just $20 for a large with four types of meat, including delivery, it was a great deal! We will definitely be ordering from here again.

I absolutely adore this restaurant; the food is amazing! They are always focused on ensuring their customers are happy. For instance, my wife called just before closing because she suddenly craved a buffalo chicken wrap. Even though they were cleaning the kitchen and preparing to close, they still made the wrap for her, and she found it delicious. Their pizza is also fantastic. I highly recommend this place to everyone!

After nearly three years, we've finally discovered a place in Middletown that serves delicious pizza.

Let's be honest from the start: the customer service here leaves much to be desired. It's a classic, old-school pizza shop, and I appreciate good food over being pampered by the staff. The pizza and grinders are truly excellent. We live nearby but had stopped coming for a while because there are so many pizza options in Middletown. We tried various new spots and artisanal pies, but on our way from CVS to Stop & Shop, we decided to stop in for a slice. Good pizza doesn’t have to be coal-fired or topped with goat cheese to be delicious. Since that quick lunch visit, we’ve started adding Big Cheese back into our regular rotation. It’s refreshing to enjoy tasty pizza without spending $25. We love the return to basics!

The food here is always fresh, and the grinders are consistently filled, unlike at Sunway. The owners and staff are very polite and respectful. I highly recommend trying the baked cheese for all your pizza and grinder needs, as well as their full menu offerings.