Newfield Pizza - Middletown

Amazing pizza for really good prices! Always have gotten a pie on a Friday/Saturday night in and it hits the spot every time!

Nothing to write home. They give you a medium-sized pizza and call it a big... You get 8 small pieces, which in the end cost you $3.00 per piece. Very expensive. You play the COVID SCAM, push the prices! Probably not back there. I wouldn't buy the grinders either, they don't have enough meat in there, only fillers with lots of bread. Oh, good.

The owner is so nice! The pizza is always really good. The prices are so much more reasonable than other pizza shops in the nearby area. I?ve always had a pleasant experience with this establishment.

My husband and I order from Newfield Pizza maybe once a week or every other week (we have very busy days with kids activities) we?ve been eating here for 6 years! From dinners, Calzones, pizza and even party pizzas for birthday parties!! The food has always been consistently good, we?ve never had an issue in regards to delivery times (they are very honest about times during busy nights) Every single delivery driver has been very professional and kind! They know my husband by face and are so sweet to my girls, which goes to show how much they value their customers! You can tell they take pride in what they do and work hard to please the customer....That?s a hard trait to find these days!!

I had their Classic American Burger and it did not disappoint. Served on a toasted roll with tomato, cheese, and lettuce, it was absolutely delicious. The staff are also very kind. I will be coming back here again. I recommend.