Bakery Plus - Middletown

Grocery, In-store Pick-up, Bakery
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Bakery Plus

Bakery Plus
4.1 / 5 (596 reviews)

Menu

On this website, you will find the complete menu of Bakery Plus from Middletown. Currently, there are 20 menus and drinks available.

Bakery Plus in Middletown, NY, is a popular American restaurant with an impressive average rating of 4.6 stars. Diners rave about the delicious food and inviting atmosphere at Bakery Plus. To make a reservation or check the restaurant's availability, simply give them a call at (845) 344-2529. If you prefer dining at home, you can also order your favorite meal from Bakery Plus through DoorDash for a quick and convenient experience. Be sure to share your dining experience with others by leaving a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: deadlysweet

Images

Bakery Plus Food Bakery Plus Food Bakery Plus Food Bakery Plus Drink Bakery Plus Inside Bakery Plus Inside Bakery Plus Logo Bakery Plus Drink

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 596 reviews

Bakery Plus has garnered a reputation for its delectable cakes and reliable service, earning loyal customers who rave about the moist texture and exceptional quality of ingredients. Many commend the friendly staff and thoughtful communication, particularly when it comes to custom orders. However, the bakery's stringent mask policies and customer interactions have drawn criticism, with some patrons finding the service rude and unprofessional. Despite these setbacks, Bakery Plus remains a go-to for those seeking delicious baked goods, showcasing a blend of quality confections and a commitment to customer health—making it a notable contender in Middletown’s bakery scene.

melissa16
30.05.2022

Exquisite pastries!! Delicious cakes! Everything at Bakery Plus is consistently excellent! Superior customer service here too. The best Hudson Valley bakery!

valentina38
30.05.2022

The cakes and pastries are sublime. Best in Hudson Valley.

weissnat-phoebe
30.05.2022

Unbelievably rude to customers. Kicks people out of the store in as nasty a way as possible, if they can't wear a mask. Get over yourself, they don't help anyone stay safe anyway. You must be pretty asleep if you still haven't figured that one out.

deadlysweet
14.01.2024

I used to buy cakes here for my birthdays, not anymore! the owner is super last minute and unprofessional these days. i couldn't get the cake i wanted because she informed me last minute she didn't have the right ingredients.

laura-vitaliani-1
14.01.2024

2 customers allowed in the store at a time. The baked goods are so worth the wait. Freshest Cakes in town!????????

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.