Bakery Plus - Middletown

I used to buy cakes here for my birthdays, not anymore! the owner is super last minute and unprofessional these days. i couldn't get the cake i wanted because s... read more I used to buy cakes here for my birthdays, not anymore! the owner is super last minute and unprofessional these days. i couldn't get the cake i wanted because she informed me last minute she didn't have the right ingredients.

2 customers allowed in the store at a time. The baked goods are so worth the wait. Freshest Cakes in town!???????? read more 2 customers allowed in the store at a time. The baked goods are so worth the wait. Freshest Cakes in town!????????

The cakes at this restaurant are truly amazing, and the family that runs it is incredibly charming! They always make you feel welcome and are happy to customize... read more The cakes at this restaurant are truly amazing, and the family that runs it is incredibly charming! They always make you feel welcome and are happy to customize your order. I highly recommend the cannoli cake with whipped cream – it is simply delightful! We enjoyed it so much that we devoured it before we could even take a photo.

I ordered an ice cream cake for my daughter's birthday, and it was a hit with everyone. We will definitely be ordering from this place again in the future. read more I ordered an ice cream cake for my daughter's birthday, and it was a hit with everyone. We will definitely be ordering from this place again in the future.

The staff at Bakery Plus are excessively focused on Covid precautions and are quite disrespectful to customers who may not be aware of their strict rules. It fe... read more The staff at Bakery Plus are excessively focused on Covid precautions and are quite disrespectful to customers who may not be aware of their strict rules. It feels as if they are still in March 2020, taking pleasure in reprimanding those who don’t adhere to their beliefs. If you’re so anxious about Covid in 2022, perhaps running a business open to the public isn’t the right fit. The only thing I enjoyed at this restaurant were the linzer tarts, but the hassle isn’t worth a return visit. I would not recommend this establishment.