J C Grill Pizza - Middleton

Steak bomb, Calzones, and Subs I have tried so far have been great!

We were really looking forward to our meal given all the great reviews, but unfortunately, we were quite disappointed. We ordered tater tots, a chicken sandwich, a Buffalo chicken wrap, and chicken noodle soup. The tots were soft and lacked crunch. The chicken sandwich seemed to have been prepared without considering our requests, as it came without mayo or American cheese. The Buffalo wrap was so messy that it had to be served in a bowl and eaten with a fork because it completely fell apart. Lastly, the chicken noodle soup tasted like it had been made a few weeks ago; the noodles were so overcooked that they had disintegrated into the broth. We ended up deciding against eating it, resulting in a wasted $7. I'm hopeful this was just an off day, since the other reviews are quite positive, but overall, we left feeling disappointed.

I often meet friends at this wonderful place! It’s my favorite restaurant for a quick meal. I try to visit at least once a month. The food is amazing, the staff is friendly, and the prices are reasonable. I really enjoy dining here for a delicious dinner.

Delicious food, friendly staff, and a consistently positive atmosphere. The prices are reasonable, and the quality of the food is outstanding. Keep up the great work!

As newcomers to the area, we’ve tried a range of items from the menu and have been delighted with 9 out of 10 of our selections. The food has been delicious, and we’ve had very friendly interactions with the staff, who are also mindful of Covid safety protocols.