Michael Anthony's - Merrick

Everything very rich ? read more Everything very rich ?

The food was unremarkable—just average, really. However, my experience at this restaurant was quite disappointing. My brother and I went there for pizza, but it... read more The food was unremarkable—just average, really. However, my experience at this restaurant was quite disappointing. My brother and I went there for pizza, but it felt eerily quiet inside, almost like a graveyard. The staff at the counter seemed to be uninterested in our presence, and there was no music or conversation among the three employees, who honestly looked like they might not get along. We felt so uncomfortable that we ended up asking for to-go boxes halfway through our meal and ate in my car while listening to Taylor Swift on the radio.

Disgusting employees, for starters a pizza place that’s not Italian is the first mistake. A delivery driver delivered my food elsewhere then picked it back up a... read more Disgusting employees, for starters a pizza place that’s not Italian is the first mistake. A delivery driver delivered my food elsewhere then picked it back up and bought it to me cold and my soda and garlic knots weren’t included. I had to wait til the next morning to call and they are just so nasty ! A Hispanic man w a heavy accent said “the boss don’t wanna refund I’ll bring you more pizza in 1 hour bye” and hung up. 3 hours later I went up there and asked for my refund and got some girl w some attitude talking about “we called you last night” only the cashier speaks English and I wasn’t leaving until I got my money. They kept tryna refer me to my bank when they the one who messed up! When I asked for the boss myself the boss gave up because she didn’t wanna talk and said give me my money back ! This is disgusting service and they need to be shut down.

Pizza was delicious. Freshly made. Warm welcoming service read more Pizza was delicious. Freshly made. Warm welcoming service

0.5 went in to check the place out ordered two plane pizzas. The pizza was horrendous paper thin. The cheese was poor quality and just was hanging onto the pizz... read more 0.5 went in to check the place out ordered two plane pizzas. The pizza was horrendous paper thin. The cheese was poor quality and just was hanging onto the pizza for dear life. Now moving onto the sauce, horrible texture left a metallic taste in my mouth as if it were out of a can. Overall horrible pizza and pice point was also high for such a sad slice I usually love pizza but today it’s a pass.