Five Guys - Merrick

#35 - Seafood - Merrick, Hamburger, Burgers
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Five Guys

Five Guys
3.5 / 5 (2808 reviews)

Description

Five Guys is a go-to destination for burger enthusiasts, known for its consistency and quality. Despite recent price increases, diners rave about the delicious burgers, extensive topping options, and a variety of inventive milkshake flavors, including unique offerings like caramel bacon. Many customers appreciate the friendly and efficient staff, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere ideal for families. However, some patrons express concerns over pricing and cooking policies, particularly regarding well-done burgers. Despite these critiques, the restaurant maintains a loyal following, with many considering it their top choice for satisfying burgers and fries.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Philip

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 2808 reviews
brad-gyorgak
24.04.2024

This is a repeat location for us after visiting Jones Beach. Clean restrooms, relaxed staff pushes our food without issue and happy to customize the cook temp on the hot dog for our particular toddler (not too crispy or char) but perfectly within food safety requirements.Kid-friendliness: Our toddler feels comfortable here and even helps bus the table to the correct bins!

sabas-montero
24.04.2024

This place has deteriorated a lot, the fries are terrible watery, the burger I give it 3

cristina-j-weed685
24.04.2024

Love five guys!! #1 burger spot when I'm craving a burger. I love that you can add as many toppings as you want and it's all part of the nice price. The service is always so fun and friendly at this location and the free peanuts and extra fries is something you can't beat

philip-r-squirrel34
24.04.2024

I was on Long Island and hungry. I've always liked 5 Guys burgers even though they've gotten more expensive post-Covid. My burger was fine. Not terrific but fine. My order of little fries almost fell out of the bag, I received so many. But, EIGHTEEN DOLLARS AND CHANGE for a burger, fries and soft drink? No. There are far too many places, not fast food joints, with better burgers for less money.

tyler-schwenk
24.04.2024

Great customer service. Food was excellent. Fries were salted to perfection and burgers were Divine. Felt like Zoidberg eating anchovies.

FAQ

The restaurant also accepts credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.