Docks - MAYVILLE

#20 - Seafood - MAYVILLE, American, North American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Docks

Docks
3.3 / 5 (545 reviews)

Menu

On this Site, you will find the complete menu of Docks from MAYVILLE. At present there are 33 meals and beverages available.

Docks in MAYVILLE, NY, is a charming American restaurant with a loyal following, currently enjoying an average rating of 3.2 stars. Known for its inviting atmosphere and a menu featuring a variety of healthy options, Docks is a great choice for dinner. Today, the restaurant welcomes guests from 5:00 PM to 10:00 PM. To ensure a great dining experience, consider calling ahead at (716) 753-2525 to check current wait times or to reserve a table. Have you dined here before? We invite you to share your experience with a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Deanna

Images

Docks Food Docks Food Docks Inside Docks Inside Docks Menu Docks Menu Docks Food Docks Food

Feedback

★ 3.3 / 5 from 545 reviews

Nestled along Route 394 with scenic lake views, this restaurant offers a cozy, lively atmosphere and friendly, welcoming service. Signature dishes like peanut butter pie, crab-stuffed walleye, prime rib specials, and fish fry receive high praise for flavor and quality. Outdoor seating and a bustling vibe add to the appeal. However, experiences vary: some guests report slow service, overpriced menus, and inconsistent food quality, including soggy buns and underwhelming sides. Cleanliness and restroom conditions have also been criticized. While the hospitality often shines, potential visitors should weigh the mixed reviews before deciding to dine here.

preinger-tree176
13.03.2023

I had an incredibly disappointing experience with the service. Given my background in the industry, I usually try to be understanding, but our server's attitude was off-putting from the start.

horacio-wisozk
13.03.2023

Our experience was truly disappointing. Three of us ordered the walleye special, but one person had to send his back after just one bite. He was wise to do so, as the other two who ate it ended up getting sick. I chose the strip steak special with mushrooms and jalapeños, but I couldn’t decide what was worse — the steak being tough and full of gristle, or the abundance of jalapeño seeds that made it too spicy to enjoy. In any case, I barely touched it. Overall, it was an expensive meal that was far from enjoyable. My husband remarked that we could have gone to McDonald's and had better fish. I did feel sorry for our waitress, as she was excellent at her job.

weldon-paucek
13.03.2023

It?s was horrible. Took 10 minutes to get seated. Then another 10 to get a waitress to take our order. Once our order was in, it took 2 hours before we got our food. And my sister got a salad, but had to wait another half hour before she actually got it. When she got it, the lettuce tasted like it had pesticide on it. The bathrooms. They?re awful. You have to side step to get in. And the bathroom light wasn?t on so you had to pee in the dark. And had to play scavenger hunt to find the toilet paper.

deanna41
15.02.2025

Had a reservation for myself and my wife for our anniversary. About half full, so not terribly busy. Sat with our menus for 20 minutes before a waitress even bothered to say I'll be with you shortly. 10 minutes later, waitress still hadn't been back tous, so we got up and walked out. 30 minutes, no glass of water, no bread, no stopping to take our drink order, NOTHING! Willnever return.

It was truly the worst service i?ve ever experienced. i come from a serving job so i try to be very understanding, but our server had a bad attitude from the start& our table was sticky when we sat. my bf ordered a bottle beer& after 40 minutes of himnot getting our beer or our server not even approaching us, we left. i will never be back& will highly discourage everyone iknow from coming.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.