Crosby's - MAYVILLE

Pizza, Italian, Delivery Services

Crosby's

Crosby's
3.0 / 5 (38 reviews)

Description

Customer experiences at this restaurant have been largely disappointing. The management is reportedly unprofessional and disrespectful, impacting both staff and patrons. Operational issues include slow and inefficient service, notably with gas pumps that take an excessive amount of time and frequently run out of common fuel options. Food quality and order accuracy have also fallen short—calls often go unanswered, online orders arrive incomplete or incorrect, and prices feel unjustified for what is served. Overall, these combined factors contribute to a frustrating visit, leaving many customers feeling undervalued and dissatisfied.

Last update: 28.06.2026 from: T

Feedback

★ 3 / 5 from 38 reviews
t-716reviewer-forest
29.09.2024

I was really disappointed with my experience at this restaurant. They never answer the phone when you call, and our online order was a complete disaster. The BLT sandwich we received had no lettuce or tomatoes, just mostly bacon, a bun, and some onion, and it was overpriced at $10.99. I've never felt so let down. To make matters worse, my daughter was unhappy with her pizza because they added pepperoni all over instead of just half cheese as we requested.

jkb
23.11.2023

Dishonest management.

np-g-1
23.11.2023

The mini mart is a suitable chain store. It’s clean and the staff is friendly. The deli offers tasty subs, the pizza sauce is a favorite among customers, and the wings are baked instead of fried.

n-delwall
23.11.2023

I enjoyed the most amazing calzone at this restaurant. The staff was extremely friendly and accommodating.

t-716reviewer
23.11.2023

I tried calling the restaurant multiple times but no one picked up. When I placed my order online, they messed it up completely. They sent a BLT that had no lettuce or tomatoes—just a few bits of bacon, a bun, and some onion for $10.99! I've never been more disappointed. My daughter didn't even like the pizza because they made it all pepperoni instead of half cheese, as we requested.

FAQ

The restaurant is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.