Subway - Mayflower

Sandwiches, American, Fast Food
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Subway

Subway
4.0 / 5 (159 reviews)

Description

The restaurant presents a mixed experience, with friendly and passionate staff like Cheyenne who create a welcoming atmosphere and engage customers thoughtfully. However, consistent issues with order accuracy, long wait times, and poor food quality—including stale bread and old vegetables—have disappointed many patrons. Online orders frequently arrive incomplete or incorrect, with additional paid items sometimes missing. While some appreciate the cozy environment and attentive service during dine-in visits, lapses in fulfilling special requests and maintaining food freshness have significantly impacted overall satisfaction, leaving several customers reluctant to return despite the potential for a strong community presence.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Chris

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 159 reviews
jim-wheeler-2
24.03.2025

We ordered 4 sandwhiches and some peperona dippers.. the worst sandwhiches i have ever gotten there. Not toasted very little meat and just horrible sandwhiches. I tried to call the store 3 times and could get no answer. If i lived close i would have taken everything back. Just wanted someone to know

jennifer-garland
13.02.2024

We visited the mayflower Subway on April 13, 2022. The service was less than satisfactory , the servers seemed too busy discussing co-workers and the fact that they couldn't show up to work or do their jobs. Brianna literally stopped twice whilemaking our sandwiches to discuss the dish situation and the co worker situation. I understand we have all dealt with people thatdon't like to work, but when there is a customer in front of you they want to feel important. I did not even feel like she caredwhether I got a sandwich or not. Then when we presented our coupon she got rude when she stated we had to make 2 separatetransactions because we had multiple sandwiches. We have been to this subway almost every Thursday since it opened and we havealways been able to pay for all the sandwiches together and use the coupon. We have never had to make 2 separate transactionsbecause we used a coupon. Whoever is in charge of this restaurant should perhaps give the employees a bit more training incustomer relations to say the least.

casey-towles
24.03.2025

I used to eat at this subway 3-4x a weekbut over the last few months it’s completely gone down hill. Our last 3 orders have all been wrong We order the same 2 subs, chips and cookies each time. Each order was an online order and I waited an hour PAST the ready by time the first time, 45 minutes past the ready by time the second and the third was ready but missing a sandwich. 1 order was missing a sandwich, 1 order had wrong sandwiches, wrong ingredients and wrong bread, and the other order they didn’t have any of what we ordered. Out of cookies, out of bread, out of meat. With only a few restaurants in Mayflower, this is a good opportunity for this location to get a lot of business.but this subway is just not good anymore. Especially for the price. Service: Take out Meal type: Other Price per person: $20–30 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

chris-kirtley-1
24.03.2025

Don't waste your time going there you definitely don't get what you paid for. And the employees definitely don't know how to make sandwiches. And when you call them on it they don't want to be honest. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

shae-s-bank125
24.03.2025

Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Cookies

FAQ

The rooms on site are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physiological disabilities.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.