Something Fishy - May Pen

Seafood, Fish, Karaoke

**Discovering Culinary Delights: A Cozy Gem in May Pen** Nestled in May Pen, this charming restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with a cozy atmosphere. Patrons rave about the freshness and flavor of the seafood dishes, which are expertly prepared to order, although some have noted occasional menu limitations. While the service is generally friendly and efficient, diners are advised to check availability beforehand, especially for seafood. Despite minor drawbacks, including a lack of complimentary water with meals, this spot has garnered a loyal following. The welcoming ambiance, intimate setting, and dedication to quality make it a must-visit culinary destination.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Cynthia

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 18 reviews

Was User at Something Fishy a mag?
As a first-time visitor, I can now say I’m a regular customer! I absolutely love the beautiful atmosphere here. The place is small and cozy, creating a nice intimate vibe. And let's talk about the food—coming from a seafood critic, I can confidently say it was delicious. I honestly couldn’t find anything bad to say! The waitress was polite and efficient, and the chef seems to take pride in her work, giving herself a... View all feedback.

What User dislikes about Something Fishy:
They food was ok, price was ok it was my girlfriend's birthday, so I didn't care too much about they price. However we went there on a Tuesday and they have no fish AT ALL, which was very disappointing. So I recommend you call ahead to see what they have on the menu available. View all feedback.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Wow, the ambiance was incredible! The food was fantastic, and the staff were very friendly!

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The atmosphere is beautiful, and the owners are wonderful hosts. Not to mention, the food is fantastic!

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

We like to eat here whenever we can. eating is the freshest and taste great. it is a clean restaurant with friendly people. we also like the ambiente, the atmosphere of the restaurant.

Cynthia 23.07.2023 - 00:18

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

As a first-time customer, I can confidently say that I will be returning regularly. The ambiance and scenery are absolutely beautiful! The cozy little restaurant is a delight, and the food is fantastic. As a seafood lover and critic, I was thoroughly impressed by the taste, flavor, and presentation—I couldn't find a single negative thing to say. Trust me on this! The waitstaff were polite and efficient, which added to the overall experience. Chef, make sure to take a moment to appreciate your hard work and consider giving yourself a raise! Well done! I visited on March 8, 2022. God bless!