Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.6 out of 5
Outstanding | 7116 reviews

What User likes about Ice Cream Cottage:
long live ice cream cottage! best ice, best people, best memories! also some popping rainbow cake! it is not too expensive, but also not cheap, but the quality shows! my personal favorite is the cherry chip! at some point I never had in this whole land cherry chip. seriously, the parking sucks, and the line is long, but it's always worth the end! View all feedback. What User doesn't like about Ice Cream Cottage:
I can’t believe how much this place has change, does John still own it? I was trying to order a large birthday cake for next day pick up and couldn’t do it on-line, so I called and told them what I was looking for wasn’t there. There response was we can’t take cake orders over the phone how ridiculous. They just lost all the birthday cake business I have been giving them over the past twenty something years. What a s... View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Menu
4.0 ★ from 15 reviews

This is the only ice that eats our family, not a big brand ice cream for us. never had a bad experience here.

Astonishingly go to the ice place. ice is always delicious, ice cream are the best. I've been there since I was a child.

Long live ice cream cottage! best ice, best people, best memories! also some popping rainbow cake! it is not too expensive, but also not cheap, but the quality...

read more

Always excellent. very friendly and friendly staff. very pleasant and patient even with difficult customers

I can’t believe how much this place has change, does John still own it? I was trying to order a large birthday cake for next day pick up and couldn’t do it on-l...

read more

Tucked away in an appealing locale, this ice cream shop is a nostalgic treasure boasting an impressive variety of flavors and toppings. Patrons rave about the quality of the ice cream, including standout options like gelato and unique flavor combinations. However, the service has faced criticism recently for being sluggish and inattentive, creating a crowded and uncomfortable atmosphere. While the prices are considered slightly high, many agree that the artisanal quality justifies the expense. Overall, this establishment remains a beloved destination for those seeking delicious treats, though future improvements in customer service are essential for returning loyal visitors.

Google
4.7 ★ from 896 reviews
Dan
07.01.2024 - 18:11

Nostalgic and delicious. The only downside is it's small and you feel crowded with just 6 people inside. Parking: Not much parking, we parked in what looks like...

read more
Tanya
07.01.2024 - 18:11

For an ice cream shop it rocks. Service: Take out Meal type: Other Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Mike
07.01.2024 - 18:11

Service: Take out Meal type: Other Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Gelato

Alexandra
07.01.2024 - 18:11

Service: 5 - The service at this restaurant was exceptional. The staff was friendly, attentive, and efficient throughout our meal. They made sure we had everyth...

read more
Kristine
07.01.2024 - 18:11

This takeout restaurant receives top ratings in all categories, including food, service, and atmosphere. With a price range of $1–$10 per person, it offers a gr...

read more
Sirved
3.0 ★ from 4 reviews
CM
25.12.2023 - 15:11

Tons of flavor choices and unique ones toppings.Sell Ice cream cakes candy. The waffle bowls are great! However don't assume you will like their version of a fl...

read more
CM
25.12.2023 - 15:11

Very nice place to create memories of an excellent ice cream. it is worth visiting and when you stop by to try the classic flavors. my suggestion is blackberry,...

read more
CM
25.12.2023 - 15:11

I am so incredibly tired of receiving incorrect orders at this place. I never leave reviews like this especially for local businesses but every single time we h...

read more
CM
25.12.2023 - 15:11

Ice cream taste wonderful. I have been coming there for several years, service use to be great. But now its poor, too many young adults working there. I waited...

read more
Int Restaurants
4.5 ★ from 1202 reviews
Kaylee
18.07.2023 - 16:40

Long live Ice Cream Cottage! Best ice cream, best people, best memories! Also some popping rainbow cakes! Its not too pricey but also not cheap, but the quality...

read more
lady
18.07.2023 - 16:40

My small Sunday was a joke...the size of a quarter whipped cream topping and maybe a tea spoon of hot fudge that was cold. One very small scoop of ice cream Cos...

read more
al
18.07.2023 - 16:40

Amazing go to ice cream spot. Ice cream is always delicious, ice cakes are the best. Highly recommend!!! Been around since I'm a kid.

Facebook
5.0 ★ from 35 reviews
Foursquare
4.1 ★ from 50 reviews
Tripadvisor
5.0 ★ from 76 reviews
Yelp
4.5 ★ from 174 reviews
Zomato
3.6 ★ from 8 reviews
Doordash
4.7 ★ from 4400 reviews
Restaurantguru
4.6 ★ from 1236 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Mastic

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Shirley (near Mastic), 924 Montauk Highway, Shirley, 11967, United States Of America
"Great coffee and they sell local honey too"
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Farmingville (near Mastic), 623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, United States
"I'm from dallas. I never had that. we have blue bell. this place is so great. I've been here 4 times now. it's like soft serve and a snow cone went on..."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Centereach (near Mastic), 1370 Middle Country Rd, 11720, Centereach, United States
"Summer staple, love Ralph's !! Everything is delicious"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Centereach (near Mastic), 1950 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, USA, 11720-3535, United States
"The Chicken Parmigiana is a masterpiece!!"
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: East Patchogue (near Mastic), 655-8 Montauk Hwy.NY 11772, East Patchogue, United States
"Everything was delicious and the evening was perfect."
4.8
Menu
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Open Now
City: Lake Ronkonkoma (near Mastic), 386 Portion Rd, 11779-2356, Lake Ronkonkoma, United States
"Unfortunately, while I love this Carvel, they do business with UberEats who ghosted my order leaving me with no delivery and having to call AmEx on Ub..."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Shirley (near Mastic), 492 William Floyd Pkwy, 11967, Shirley, United States
"Dirty and old. Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Baiting Hollow (near Mastic), 100 Fox Hill Dr, 11933, Baiting Hollow, US, United States
"Excellent venue for a wedding. One of the best on the northfork."
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Mastic, 1226 Montauk Hwy, 11950, Mastic, United States
"Easily the best Italian food in Mastic"
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Mastic, 1171 Montauk Highway, Mastic, 11950, United States Of America
"Great food. My favorite is the mixed grill."