Crafted Coffee - Madison

Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Crafted Coffee

Crafted Coffee
4.7 / 5 (138 reviews)

Menu

A complete overview of all 24 courses and drinks can be found here on the menu of Crafted Coffee from Madison.

Nestled in Madison, Crafted Coffee has garnered a diverse range of opinions from patrons. While some diners rave about the outstanding food, including flavorful bagels and standout sandwiches, others have experienced long wait times and service inconsistencies, particularly during busy weekends. The café’s inviting atmosphere and the friendly staff receive praise, yet concerns about food safety practices and staffing levels have emerged. Despite these issues, many guests cherish their visits, with highlights including delicious coffee selections and mouthwatering pastries. Overall, Crafted Coffee is a gem worth exploring, especially for food lovers eager to enjoy delightful offerings in a cozy setting.

Last update: 02.02.2026 from: Kennedi

Images

Crafted Coffee Food Crafted Coffee Food Crafted Coffee Food Crafted Coffee Food Crafted Coffee Food Crafted Coffee Food

Feedback

★ 4.7 / 5 from 138 reviews

Was Abraham Willms at Crafted Coffee a mag?
As a foodie from Dallas, Texas who moved to Madison three years ago, I have been pleasantly surprised by the food scene here. Crafted Coffee is a standout for me, offering a cozy and comfortable atmosphere to enjoy a delicious cup of coffee. My personal favorite is the ham and cheese panini, which is absolutely delicious. View all feedback.

What Abraham Willms dislikes about Crafted Coffee:
Waited 45 minutes for my coffee. Ended up just leaving it and going down the road to a gas station to get a coffee. It was Regatta weekend but the guys behind the counter were in no hurry.As we were leaving another customer said I’ve been waiting 1 hr 15 minutes. That’s an unacceptable wait for coffee. View all feedback.

abraham33
22.10.2022

As a foodie from Dallas, Texas who moved to Madison three years ago, I have been pleasantly surprised by the food scene here. Crafted Coffee is a standout for me, offering a cozy and comfortable atmosphere to enjoy a delicious cup of coffee. My personal favorite is the ham and cheese panini, which is absolutely delicious.

brown-kaylie-squirre
22.10.2022

I absolutely adore this restaurant! Their coffee selection is top-notch and they really know how to grill a bagel to perfection. The staff are also very friendly and cool.

pwilliamson-1
22.10.2022

The coffee and breakfast sandwich were both tasty, and the building, inside and out, was stunning. We will definitely return!

hlittle-2
29.04.2023

I tried the new Cobb Salad today, and it was absolutely delicious! Everything is made fresh to order, so it takes a bit longer than at a fast food restaurant. However, the wait is definitely worth it for a fantastic drink and excellent food!

akthm-lhsyn
29.04.2023

They 've recently redone the inside decor and changed their menu slightly. I 've had their breakfast Toad N Hole and it was delicious! I 'm not much for sweet coffee drinks but I appreciate the half cut sweet iced almond milk latte that I got, and they were willing to put that in my own coffee cup which I appreciate a ton!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.