Trattoria Il Cafone - Lyndhurst

Wonderful service and great selections from the menu. Me and my girlfriend are regular customers because the food is so good . Highly recommend Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Zuppa Di Pesce

We heard that Roberto was back and that the restaurant is back to the way it was years ago. So after 3 years, we went back and it was phenomenal! I had my old favorite, pappardelle al forno. Amazing. My husband asked if they had eggplant rollatini but it wasn't on the menu. The chef said that was no problem prepared it for him. It was also amazing. He then had gnocchi bolognese and said it was the best he ever had. All the wait staff is attentive and so pleasant! Juan is the best. Our favorite once again. Can't wait till next time...

I hadn 't been here in years so shame on me. Great food, great people, great service, great prices especially for quality and quantity of food served. BYOB. Open seating in a spacious but cozy atmosphere. Can 't wait to go back and try the thin crust pizza but call first to see if the pizza man is on duty but don 't fret if he isn 't, all entrees are wonderfully prepared and listen closely to the specials.

Rating: 100/100! I have been a loyal customer at this restaurant for years. The food is consistently amazing and full of flavor. The service is exceptional, although they have been short-staffed since 2020 like many other businesses, so it may be a bit slower. However, they make up for it with their above-and-beyond service. The atmosphere is warm and cozy, making it a perfect spot for a dinner date or a girls' night out. They offer alcohol, but you can also bring your own. Prices are reasonable. I highly recommend this restaurant! Wheelchair accessibility is easy, as it is located on the ground level.