Pizza Mill - Limerick

Italian, Lunch, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Pizza Mill

Pizza Mill
3.5 / 5 (271 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Pizza Mill in Limerick. At the moment, there are 18 meals and drinks on the list.

The Peppermill Restaurant in Limerick, ME, is a charming American eatery with a solid average rating of 3.7 stars. Open from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, it's the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings. Curious about the dining experience? Many visitors have shared their thoughts on the great food and welcoming atmosphere. If you’d like to inquire about the restaurant's busyness or make a reservation, feel free to call (207) 793-2500. In addition to a delicious menu, the restaurant proudly offers healthy options. If you're feeling adventurous, consider trying Dough Boy Donuts and Pizza Mill for a delightful change! Don't forget to share your own experience by leaving a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Ken

Images

Pizza Mill Food Pizza Mill Drink Pizza Mill Outside Pizza Mill Menu Pizza Mill Menu Pizza Mill Menu

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 271 reviews

In a charming yet chaotic setting, this Limerick restaurant captivates diners with its promise of delightful food and warm hospitality, though experiences vary significantly. Many patrons rave about the pizza, often hailed as the best in Maine, while others express dissatisfaction with slow service and quality control, citing issues such as soggy buns and unseasoned appetizers. Staffing challenges are evident during busy hours, affecting service efficiency and creating frustration among both guests and employees. Despite these hiccups, the appealing atmosphere and friendly staff invite a second chance for a memorable dining experience, making it a local gem worth exploring.

pamela-allen
13.11.2023

I ordered a chicken spinach Alfredo pizza, but when I got home, it had red sauce on it. I returned to the restaurant, and they prepared the correct pizza for me. However, it looked like it had been dropped on the floor—it was unacceptable. I will not be returning there again. Service: Takeout Meal Type: Dinner Price Range: $10–$20

sharleen-shea
13.11.2023

Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20

michael-dometilie
13.11.2023

Some of the locals seemed to feel uncomfortable with our presence as out-of-towners. After experiencing a verbal and physical altercation, management asked us to leave.

ken-davis-restaurant-2
16.04.2025

This is a local place in Limerick and it's very casual. I did not have a very good experience. The staffing was very light. I think there was only one cook, a bartender server, and a local guy who pitched in to help who wasn't on the payroll. I didn'tcare. He was helping with logistics and getting tables ready and helping the two employees with getting what they needed toserve patrons. The owner or manager is to blame for this. I could hear the frustration in the bartender when you were making adrink or menu decision. She in fact walked away to other patrons. I only ordered a beer. 30 seconds adds up when you have 20other people putting in food and drink orders....as in 10 minutes plus. Which can seem like a long time to a patron. My Chicagohot dog was $13. It was big but it wasn't very good. The bun was soggy and wet, and for a hot dog that is $13 it should havebeen better. I may give this another try. I blame the experience on poor staffing on a Saturday night.

gods-chosen-3
16.04.2025

Another place to eat in the middle of nowhere. But that does not affect it's taste. They still put the effort to make everything taste so yummy. I recommend this place and the people are great. You'll feel at home.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.