Ice Cream Plus - Lapel

Literally sitting here w 1 customer ahead of me and have been waiting on 2 single scoops of ice cream going on 10 minutes. And then finally I get them and one i... read more Literally sitting here w 1 customer ahead of me and have been waiting on 2 single scoops of ice cream going on 10 minutes. And then finally I get them and one is cookies and cream, not moose tracks as ordered not sure what these teens are doing and I don’t think they do either.

After craving a sweet treat all day, I was so excited when I drove by Ice Cream Plus on the way to dinner! I spent my dinner dreaming of a soft-serve cone, and... read more After craving a sweet treat all day, I was so excited when I drove by Ice Cream Plus on the way to dinner! I spent my dinner dreaming of a soft-serve cone, and my dessert definitely lived up to my expectations! The menu boasted overly 20 options for toppings, as well as several flavor bursts (flavored syrup drizzles) hard and soft ice cream, and even savory sandwich and sides! I got a classic vanilla-chocolate twist, which was simple yet delicious. My waffle cone was also fresh and crunchy. My sister chose a flurry (ICP 's equivalent of a DQ Blizzard) with a cake batter flavor burst and cookie dough pieces. She loved that she got to pick her own flavor instead of just getting the traditional vanilla. The prices were very reasonable, certainly cheaper than the ice cream places in Fishers. The outside seating area is very cute, with picnic tables, giant checkers, and ICP 's signature advertisement sign, always emblazoned with quippy quotes. The only reason why I 'm docking a star is because the service was quite slow and they were out of several ingredients.

Disappointed. I'd give this place another try and better review if I received a better quality cone or treat. Granted, this day was HOT but the dipped cone had... read more Disappointed. I'd give this place another try and better review if I received a better quality cone or treat. Granted, this day was HOT but the dipped cone had a very thin coating as if it was the bottom of the barrel so it was watered down with syrup. Because of that, and the heat, it became an awful mess. If my assessment was correct and there wasn't enough chocolate to properly coat two cones, we shouldn't have been offered this as it's a poor representation of their ice cream.

I wish I could give this restaurant a zero-star rating. I have visited multiple times and they frequently mess up my order, whether it's the size of the item or... read more I wish I could give this restaurant a zero-star rating. I have visited multiple times and they frequently mess up my order, whether it's the size of the item or the toppings. Despite wanting to support local businesses, I decided to give them another chance. Unfortunately, this time I ordered a hot fudge sundae and received a bowl with burnt hot fudge at the bottom, with no hot fudge on top likely because it had hardened due to being burnt. I will not be returning and do not recommend this place. Save your money.

This restaurant would greatly improve if they did not have high school students working alone in the evening without adult supervision. The three girls working... read more This restaurant would greatly improve if they did not have high school students working alone in the evening without adult supervision. The three girls working on a Thursday evening seemed to be inexperienced and made several mistakes with customers' orders. One customer's banana split even arrived without the banana! There is a need for immediate management restructuring.