Turkey Lake Tavern - Lagrange

Food, American, Delivery Services
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Turkey Lake Tavern

Turkey Lake Tavern
4.4 / 5 (1819 reviews)

Description

In recent visits to a well-known local eatery, patrons have expressed mixed sentiments about their dining experiences. While some guests celebrated the quality of fish tacos and burgers, describing the latter as “awesome” and highlighting tasty tartar sauce, others were disappointed by overcooked fish sandwiches and slow service. Frustration arose not only from food quality but also from lengthy waits for attention from staff. Despite the high prices, many continue to remember the establishment's former glory. Overall, while the restaurant retains its loyal following, guests hope for improvements in food consistency and service to restore its esteemed reputation.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Kelly

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 1819 reviews
kelly-miller-weed4
16.10.2024

My fish tacos were excellent. They are one of only two fish dishes that aren’t fried. The others in my party enjoyed their food too the service was good. It’s not a fancy place but from what some lake people tell us, it’s one of the best in the area.

julia-hany
16.10.2024

Best fish around! Absolutely amazing service incredible owners too

bread
16.10.2024

I always get the 4-piece fish dinner. Plenty of food if you are very hungry. House salad dressing is fantastic, and the tartar sauce is the best I have ever had.

me-me-flower05
16.10.2024

Good fried fish, with excellent tarter sauce.

ralph-daniels-3
16.10.2024

OTR DRIVERS Delivered a load of fish here. If you so happen to deliver here. You need to enter where it says ENTER. STAY WIDE RIGHT. TURN LEFT IMMEDIATELY DOWN THIS LITTLE DRIVEWAY THAT'S BEHIND THEIR BUILDING. YOU'LL UNDERSTAND WHY YOU SHOULD'VE STAYED WIDE RIGHT ENTERING. IT'S A TREE THAT YOUR TRAILER WILL CLEAR IF DONE CORRECTLY. I DO NOT RECOMMEND TAKING THE STREET AHEAD OF YOU WHEN ENTERING THE RESTAURANT. IT DOES WRAP AROUND. IT'S JUST FOLKS HOUSES AND CAN GET REAL MESSY, REAL FAST FOR YA! 10/10:30am someone will be there. They open 11am. Their fish was high in reviews. So I wanted to see what the fuss was about. I personally think on a scale of 10. It's a 6/7. It's that tartar sauce that gives it that pop. So solid 8. The Colossal Shrimp I wanted to turn back around for. OMG they were prepared and cooked just right. Nice batter of a crunch to complement the shrimp. I wish they had some grits to go with them. They do not serve breakfast. Overall my experience was nice. I'd come to deliver or stop by if passing thru again

FAQ

You can use the WiFi of the place at no extra cost.

The place also takes credit cards from the common providers for payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.