Casey's - Kokomo

Breakfast, Lunch, Pizza

Casey's

★ 4.1 / 5 (152 reviews)

Casey’s offers a convenient, welcoming experience with quick service, friendly staff, and thoughtful touches like free air for tires and a well-stocked lottery selection. Many praise the consistently excellent cheesebread and pizza, though some recent orders have reported undercooked dough and excessive crust. Standout employees like Tim enhance the customer experience by going above and beyond. Overall, Casey’s remains a beloved local spot known for quality food and attentive service, though a few recent quality inconsistencies suggest room for improvement. Despite this, its commitment to customer satisfaction keeps patrons coming back.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Clotilde

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 152 reviews

Was Rasmus Salo at Casey's a mag?
I had cheesebread and a pepperoni pizza topped with peppers and sausage. It was absolutely delicious and prepared really quickly after I placed my order. The pizza and bread were both excellent! View all feedback.

What Lowell Reichel dislikes about Casey's:
Usually it’s great pizza but here lately the pizza has not been cooked. The dough is raw and I’m not sure what they are doing but it’s usually wet as well. When I have to put it in my oven to cook it there is something wrong. View all feedback.

Rasmus

06.02.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

I had cheesebread and a pepperoni pizza topped with peppers and sausage. It was absolutely delicious and prepared really quickly after I placed my order. The pizza and bread were both excellent!

Jorge

06.02.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

I really appreciate that they offer free air for tires and quick service. The staff is always helpful and polite. I bought some lottery tickets here, and I have a good feeling about winning since this is my favorite spot for scratch-offs. I actually won a nice amount, and the cashier even put a tip into the register. Overall, this is my favorite local fuel station. They have a great selection of lottery games, and the place is always clean and well-stocked. I just wish it were closer to my home!

Lindsay

06.02.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

It was Thanksgiving Day, and I was craving pizza. Unfortunately, all the pizza places near my apartment were closed. So, I decided to call Casey's and place an order. They truly went above and beyond to ensure my order was perfect. I highly recommend them, and I will definitely be returning for more pizza in the future!

Clotilde

06.02.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Every time I come here, I'm greeted by the same cash. his name is tim, and he puts extra 110% for not only me as a customer, but also for other customers. I wish they could be as good everywhere as tim! thank you tim!