Sarabeth's - Key West
Sarabeth's
Menu
The restaurant from Key West offers 96 different dishes and drinks on the menu for an average price of $18.5.
Fresh and modern American dishes crafted by a James Beard award-winning chef. Our menu features fluffy omelets, scratch-made pancakes, fresh salads, delicious sandwiches, and grilled meats and fish. Enjoy a selection of beer and affordably priced wines. Dine indoors or outdoors at our historic clapboard landmark building from the 1800s in the heart of Old Town. We can't wait to welcome you!.
Images
Reservation request for Sarabeth's
Feedback
Sarabeth's restaurant, known for its upscale but unpretentious dining atmosphere, has recently undergone ownership changes, leading to mixed reviews from loyal patrons. Some have expressed disappointment with the new owners, citing unfriendly service, higher prices, and smaller portions compared to the previous owner, Milosh, who was known for his warm hospitality. Despite these changes, some diners have still enjoyed the excellent food offerings, such as the whole yellowtail snapper and coconut curry rice, as well as special themed nights like Sunday fried chicken, which have exceeded expectations. While some patrons have had issues with dining room mosquitoes, others have raved about the friendly staff, fabulous food, and quaint ambiance of the restaurant. Overall, Sarabeth's appears to have a mix of loyal customers and those seeking a more consistent dining experience.
This place is famous for its breakfast so I was very pleased to find out that dinner here is just as great.
Sarabeth's is located in a historic building from the 1800s right in Old Town.
Came here with my family as our first stop in key west.
The restaurant in Key West had the best food we've ever had. We highly recommend it. It's a disappointment that they are closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, or else we would have dined there every day during our 4-day stay. The food was delicious enough that we were tempted to try other items on the menu.
We had an early reservation at this restaurant on 8/23. They have both indoor and outdoor seating options, but due to the hot weather, we chose to sit inside. The dining area was comfortable and despite a few other tables being occupied, the noise level was not a problem. We were pleasantly surprised to find a variety of appetizers and a Prix Fixe menu available. The Prix Fixe menu allowed us to choose from the regular menu for a first course, main course, and dessert. My wife opted for the whole yellowtail snapper, deboned and flash fried, standing upright on the plate and stuffed with arugula, fennel, cherry tomato salad, and citrus soy vinaigrette. I selected the coconut curry rice with shrimp on a bed of coconut rice and red curry sauce, accompanied by sautéed spinach. Both dishes were delightful. The menu also featured various seafood options, steak for meat lovers, and a unique array of desserts.
Full Menu
Featured Items
Roasted Fresh Red Beets With Gorgonzola Cheese$9.0 Our Grilled Caesar Salad$9.0 Green Chili Pepper Mac-N-3-Cheese$11.0 Sarabeth's Velvety Cream Of Tomato Soup$9.0Main Course
A Key West Favorite, Our Own Shellfish Cake$27.0 Sautéed Filet Of Salmon With Garden Herbs$27.0
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.3 / 5 (9806 reviews)Caribbean Cuban SeafoodMangoes Restaurant and Catering - Key West, FL
700 Duval St Key West, FL 33040, 33040-7433, United States
"This is my favorite restaurant in the city!"
★ 4.4 / 5 (1249 reviews)Caribbean Seafood Hotels Venues CoffeeOne Duval
One Duval St. Key West, FL 33040, 33040-6676, United States
"Excellent as always...our third time to visit and will be back"
★ 4.5 / 5 (12186 reviews)#20 Vegetarian in Key West SeafoodA&B Lobster House
Front Street 700, 33040 Key West, US
"Great food, great service and Very clean place. Friendly staff"