Angelina's Pizzeria - Feedback

A Favorite among the Locals. This is one of the favored pizza restaraunts preferred by the locals. It is a step above most other pizza places, they do pile on t...

Good Pizza for the Crawl. Not necessarily the best pizza on the rock (I vote Big Johns for that), but it is a good slice to grab while doing the Duval Crawl. I...

Good street pizza.... Street pizza is any pizza sold directly over a counter or from a truck and consumed outdoors. This street pizza is among the best in KW. A...

Pizza was good. Good prices also, 3.50 a slice, and the slices are big. Cool atmosphere and awesome music

Great Little Place. I loved this place, and I am much harder on judging pizza joints than any other place, it was a little pricey for slices but given the locat...

Ordered a pizza for 10 pm, they brought it 2 hours early! However, the pizza is Really Good!

The service was great but the pizza tasted like old cheese. It tasted weird and old. ?‍?

Love that they offer pizza by the slice with whatever toppings you desire. It is served hot from the oven, and they have tables and chairs nearby. Conveniently...

Went here once in 2023, and had to come back. The turtle pond is nice and so is the shaded area on those hot summer days. Good pizza, good people...and yes, I p...

Ordered, paid for it, and waited forever and never got our pizza. Argued with us that we got it. This was in July. Asked for a refund and the refund was $22.50....

Some of the BEST pizza I’ve had after a night of drinking! My only regret is that I only got one slice

Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had, don’t know why this place isn’t closer to 5 stars, but whatever. If you’re in key west and want some pizza, come here. Don’...

Growing up in NY/NJ and eating pizza weekly this pizza hit the spot! Traditional NY style with a crispy under-carriage and a nice flop. Mr.Portny needs to hit t...

It's a cozy little pizza spot on Duval Street. The pizza is decent, though it tastes better after a few drinks. The service, however, was excellent!

The pizza is very delicious and of high quality—perfect! I can highly recommend it.

Despite the mixed reviews, we decided to stop by for some late-night pizza after visiting other places for drinks. The staff was friendly, and the pizza was tru...

A pretty good pizza spot located in the heart of Key West on Duval Street. We were eager to grab a bite after finally finding parking in downtown Key West...

I stopped in for a pastry and it exceeded my expectations. It was freshly baked and served hot! The place has a small seating area and a countertop with all the...